Currently Being Moderated

Photos 1.5 vs iPhoto 9.6.1:  Features and Capabilities

I've created a table comparing the iPhoto features to Photos V 1.5.  I've not used some of the Photos' editing features but think I've included all of them.  Please feel free to let me know about those I've left out or misrepresented.

 

Also tell Apple what missing features you'd like restored in Photos via  Apple-Photos Feedback.

 

iPhoto 9.6.1 vs Photos 1.5 Features

 

iPhoto 9.6.1

Photos 1.5

GENERAL

 

 

Item Counts

All items in sidebar, Events and

Photos (when Event Title selected)

Total count of all items is displayed in All

Photos, albums and smart albums windows.

In the Photos window the count is broken

down to photos and videos at the bottom of the window.

 

 

 

FILE FORMATS SUPPORTED

JPEG, GIF, TIFF, PNG, PSD

JPEG, GIF, TIFF, PNG, PSD, PDF, AUDIO

 

 

 

METADATA

 

 

Adjust Date and Time

Yes

Yes

Batch Title Rename with sequential nos.

Yes

No

Batch Change Title, Date or Description

Yes

No

Star Ratings

Yes

No (converted to keywords)

Flagged

Yes

No (converted to keywords)

Favorite

No

Yes

Flag Photo

Yes

No

Description

Yes - images, albums and events

Yes - images only

Keywords

Yes

Yes

Exporting Metadata

Only exports and writes

metadata to JPEG files

Exports and writes metadata to JPEG and

RAW files (if original exported with XMP file)

 

 

 

FACES

Yes - images, albums and events

Yes - images only

Hide face names

Yes - via Info pane

Yes -via View menu

 

 

 

ORIGINAL IMAGE FILES

 

 

Referenced

Yes

Yes

Managed

Yes

Yes

In Cloud

No

Yes

Reveal in Finder - Managed Files

Yes

No

Reveal in Finder - Referenced Files

Yes

Yes

Hidden in Events/Moments

Yes

Yes

Hidden in Albums

Yes

No

Can be Relinked

No

Yes

Can be Consolidated

No

Yes

 

 

 

ALBUMS

 

 

Sort Photos by Date or Title

Yes

Yes

Ascending/Descending

Both

Both

Sort Photos by Keyword, Rating

Yes

No

Set Key Photo

Yes - Events and Albums

Yes - Albums

 

 

 

SMART ALBUM CRITERIA

 

 

Events, Places

Yes

No

Star Ratings

Yes

No (uses keywords)

Lens

No

Yes

Refer to other Smart Albums

No

No

Refer to Projects (books, calendars, etc.)

Yes

No

Faces

Yes

Yes - but no "Unnamed" option

 

 

 

SLIDESHOWS

 

 

Sort Audio Tracks by Playing Time

Yes

No

Sort Audio Tracks by Artist

Yes

No

Sort Audio Tracks by Song

Yes

No

Display Album Tracks with Album Title

No

Yes

Display Playlists

Yes

No

Search Audio Tracks by Album/Artist/Song

Yes

Yes

No. of Themes

12

8

Title Slide

Yes

No

Add Text to Slides

Titles, Descriptions, Titles and

Descriptions, Dates or Locations

Just User Added Text to Each Slide

Shuffle slides

Yes - when playing

slideshow from album.

No

Transitions

15 User Selectable for Some Themes

Only the Default Transition for All Theme

 

 

 

BOOKS

 

 

Types

Hardcover, Softcover, Wire-bound

Square (HC) , Classic (HC), Softcover

Bindings

Hardcover, Softcover, Wire-bound

Hardbound, Softcover

Sizes

Hardcover (L, XL)

Softcover (L,M,S),

Wire-bound (L,M)

Square (10x10, 8x8)

Classic (13x10, 11x8.5)

Softcover (8x8, 6x6)

Themes

18

21

See Theme General Layout Before Selecting

Yes

No

Order Books from Apple after March 31, 2016

No

Yes

 

 

 

CALENDARS

 

 

Themes

10

10

See Theme General Layout Before Selecting

Yes

No

Order Calendars from Apple after March 31, 2016

No

Yes

 

 

 

CARDS

 

 

Types

Letterpress, Folded, Flat

Letterpress, Folded, Flat

Orientation

Landscape

Portrait, Landscape

Themes

Folded - 75

Flat - 75

Letterpress - 31

Letterpress - 31

Folded/Flat - 19 Portrait
Folded Flat - 17 Landscape

See Theme General Layout Before Selecting

Yes

No

Order Cards from Apple after March 31, 2016

No

Yes

 

 

 

MAPS

 

 

Add/Edit Locations

Yes

Yes

Pins at Locations

Yes

Yes - in Info pane for Albums,

Smart Albums, Photos, All Photos

No - thumbnails for Moments, Collections, Years

Single Map for All Photos

Yes

Yes - in small Info pane for Albums,

Smart Albums, Photos, All Photos

Yes - full sized for Moments, Collections, Years

Custom Names for Locations

Yes

No

Show Albums on Map

Yes

No

 

 

 

EDITING

 

 

Effects/Filters

9 Effects:

Darken, Contrast, Cooler,

Saturate, Sepia, Antique, Matte,

Vignette, Edge Blur, Boost, None

10 Filters:

None, Mono, Tonal, Noir, Fade,

Chrome, Process, Transfer, Instant

Tools

Rotate, Enhance, Fix Red-Eye,

Straighten, Crop, Retouch

Enhance, Rotate, Crop/Straighten,

Flip, Horizontal & Vertical, Filters,

Retouch, Red Eye, Extensions

Crop

Crop size ratio defaults to last used

Yes

No

Automatic Straighten

No

Yes

Flip

No

Yes

Adjust/ADJUSTMENTS

•Levels •Exposure
•Contrast
•Saturation w/skin tone control

•Definition

•Highlights

•Shadows

•Sharpness

•De-noise

•Temperature
•Tint

•Histogram

•Light: Exposure, Highlights, Shadows,

Brightness, Contrast, Black Point (skin tone)

•Color: Saturation, Contrast, Cast
•Black & White: Intensity, Neutrals, Tone, Grain

•Sharpen: Intensity, Edges, Falloff

•Definition

•Noise Reduction

•Vignette: Strength, Radius, Softness

•White Balance: Neutral Gray

•Skin Tone, Temperature/Tint

•Levels

Copy and paste adjustments between photos

Yes

Yes

Toggle between original and edited version

Yes - Shift key

Yes - M key

3rd party editor

Yes - via preferences

Yes - via individual app extensions

and

External Editors For Photos

Editing in slideshow mode

Yes - double click on the slide

Yes - double click on the thumbnail

 

 

 

Replies

Delete User Tip

Are you sure you want to delete this user tip?