Currently Being ModeratedDec 5, 2011 12:06 AM (in response to sherunswest)
I have the iOS update and this problem is still happening. I was looking for an answer to that problem today in the Support Community when I found what I think will help. There is a Default Alert Times setting. Go to Settings > Mail, Contact, Calendars > scroll to Calendars: Default Alert Times > There are 3 possible defaults (in iOS 5.0.1) Birthdays, Events and All-Day Events. I set my Events default to 1 hour and now when I create an appointment/event my First Alert is automatically 1 hour. I can then set my 2nd alert and it didn't reverse like you described above. I just did one test today, so I still have to monitor it for awhile. So in your case you should be able to set your default to 1 day and just enter your 2nd alert as desired whenever you create an appointment. Of course you change the 1st alert to whatever you want when you create your appointment. It seems to stop the reversal of the alerts though. I was glad to see that. We shouldn't have to do this, but it's better than nothing. Maybe they'll fix it someday. Hope this works for you.
Currently Being ModeratedDec 5, 2011 9:46 PM (in response to Glimpsis)
Thanks so much for that. I have set my Events to default to 1 day before and add in my second alert when I create a new event. Just tested it out and there is no reversal. I'll keep an eye on this but looks to be working fine by doing it this way. Thanks again for the tip.
Currently Being ModeratedDec 11, 2011 4:34 PM (in response to sherunswest)
I have had the same problem since the ios update. I did as Glimpsis suggested, and set the default alert time. I always have two alerts however, so now, when I add the second alert, or enter two completely different alert times, it always reverts back to the default time, reversed. It takes two or three tries to get it to stick the way I want it. This is fantastically annoying, and I think, the first true bug I have ever experienced with any iPhone in four years. All I want for Christmas is a new update....
Currently Being ModeratedDec 11, 2011 7:47 PM (in response to Shidliwink)
Since posting my suggestion to set a default alert time, I've found that it helps, but does not solve the problem. I have set a default 1st alert of 1 day and most of the time I just have to set my 2nd alert and the alerts aren't reversed. Sometimes I change the 1st alert and add a 2nd alert and they don't reverse either. However, at other times the alerts still reverse and the 1st alert becomes the 2nd alert. As I said in my first post I was monitoring to see if it solved the problem and it has not. The bug is there and it's a drag. Does anyone from apple ever read these comments? The Calendar app is disappointing. In addition to the alerts bug, you can't set an appointment to occur on a specific day of the week (like every 3rd Mon.) - Just by date, every week, every two weeks, ect. That's annoying too and needs to be fixed.
Currently Being ModeratedDec 22, 2011 4:42 AM (in response to sherunswest)
I have this same issue. Moreover, because these reverse, I'm NEVER alerted!! I wonder if we didn't set the default reminder and simply set an alert for each event we create if that would "solve" the issue?
Currently Being ModeratedJan 2, 2012 5:13 PM (in response to sherunswest)
I have had the same issue. Sometimes it stays the way I have put it in, and other times it swtiches the two. I have also noticed that even after it shows "correct" it has flipped on me after some time. I have only noticed this with the 4s not the 3Gs.
Currently Being ModeratedJan 3, 2012 12:14 AM (in response to dadpays)
The problem exists with or without use of the default. When setting your alerts, it seems to help if you immediately go back into the calendar item and reset the alerts after saving the item. We shouldn't have to do this though. I've seen a lot of articles about Apple wanting the iPhone to catch on in business enterprises. How do they expect to do that if they can't deliver a fully functional calendar app? You can't create a recurring appointment that occurs on the same day every two weeks either. This is a sad calendar app.
Currently Being ModeratedJan 3, 2012 3:46 PM (in response to Cessna340)
Still struggling with this bug, and like Cessna340 experienced, I find that alerts I have corrected tend to reverse again after a while. I am getting all kinds of perversions: reversals, doubles, spontaneous (alert times I have not manually entered--the iPhone chooses for me!) It is an ugly, ugly game. I am missing appointments because when the alerts are reversed, neither is triggered to go off. BTW, this is happening on my 3Gs, which I was perfectly happy with before this bug hopped a ride on iOS5. Today I restored my phone, and I think all it did was reverse ALL my alert times. With no offical response to this discussion, or emails, I am at my wits' end. I am going in for an appointment at the Genius bar. Anyone else had any luck getting help for this problem?
Currently Being ModeratedJan 4, 2012 6:52 AM (in response to Shidliwink)
I went to the Apple store when I noticed this first happening (early November) and the guys at the Genius Bar hadn't seen this before and couldn't offer a solution. They thought maybe the update that was coming out shortly after I was in would solve but in the end it didn't. Not sure that if you go now they'll know any more. Perhaps they've seen the issue more and have some ideas to try and fix. I'm still baffled and missing alerts.
Currently Being ModeratedFeb 7, 2012 9:38 AM (in response to sherunswest)
Update since Genius visit:
1) Apple is working on an update
2) There is no awareness at Apple of this calendar alert issue as a bug, hence it is not being addressed/worked on
3) Solutions offered by Genius have not resolved this issue.
Solutions offered by Genius, in order of which to try first:
1) Delete calendar data from iPhone: Settings>iCloud>Calendars OFF and then restore data from iCloud: Calendars ON
2) Reset iPhone settings: Settings>General>Reset>Reset all settings
3) Restore to factory settings: Settings>General>Reset>Erase all content and settings, then restore data from iCloud and in-app backups.
4) Use another calendar app (seriously)
Of course, if the bug is actually part of the iOS software (could it be?) then no amount of erasing and restoring data will fix the issue. I completed the first two options with no change, and am not willing to do the third option because I am not interested in going through the process of backing up, then restoring all my third-party apps.
My solution: raise awareness of this issue with Apple, so that it can be worked on and fixed. I have reported it as a bug through Apple's feedback module: http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphone.html and I encourage-- no, ask-- you to do the same, if you are experiencing this issue. I provided a link to this forum topic to show the variety and detail of problems.
Are you sick of missing alerts, fiddling endlessly, coming up with workarounds, paying for unreliable software, and not being responded to? I am. It's time to rally!
Currently Being ModeratedFeb 15, 2012 9:07 PM (in response to sherunswest)
This is a bug that surfaced with the iOS5 update the version/model of phone makes no difference. Virtually every iOS update has seriously screwed up my contacts and calendars. I don't understand why Apple can't get it right and keep it that way...