8 Replies Latest reply: Oct 30, 2012 9:03 AM by Aye Es Oh
Gammaray2000 Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

I am considering switching from Adobe Photoshop Eelements to Aperture and am searching available manuals and instructions on Apple's website.

 

I could not find instrauctions how to remove objects (persons) from a photo.

 

Can this be done withion aperture or do I need an app?


iMac, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.2)
  • 1. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    Frank Caggiano Level 7 Level 7 (23,795 points)

    For doing what you want to do, removing an object from an image, you need an image editor/graphics program along the lines of Photoshop or GIMP.

     

    Aperture is capable of working with such a program to manage the images and to do the initial development of the image from the camera but does not do that type of image manipulation.

     

    regards

  • 2. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    Gammaray2000 Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    Thanks!

  • 3. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    stanleyd Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    I've done some minor manipulation of the type you need using the retouch brush. I set it to "Clone" and then as in Photoshop one performs an option-click to select the area to use as a replacement for the pixels depicting the "persons" you wish to remove. It's a bit tedious but it works within Aperture. I can rarely do this in one movement –– that is to say –– I do it with the opacity set high, then again from a different clone of pixels at a lesser opacity and then a final opacity of pixels than provide a light cover to "polish" the maneuver. I was pleasantly surprised to find the capability with the Aperture App.

  • 4. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    léonie Level 9 Level 9 (51,640 points)

    If you want a compositing program especially for removing large objects, try Inpaint. It is very good, but not free (about 19 $US). You can download a trial here: http://www.theinpaint.com

     

    It is very simple to use: Just drag the mouse over the area you want to remove and Inpaint will it fill automatically with a texture from your image that fits best into the area you want to clear.

     

    For example:

    Original image:

    P1090785.png

     

    To remove the moon:

    Drag the mouse over the region - it will be marked red:

    inpaitmarked.png

    Press the blue "Inpaint" arrow and the region will be replaced by some best fitting texture picked from the image:

     

    P1090785cleared.png

     

    Essentially Inpaint does automatically what stanleyd described, but in a way that will work with really large regions to be patched.

     

    Regards

    Léonie

  • 5. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    stanleyd Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    Thanks Léone… that's a much more elegant solution and it appears to be a real time saver as well.

  • 6. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    léonie Level 9 Level 9 (51,640 points)

    But your method is free - built in - and preserves Apertures lossless workflow. For small objects I use it frequently, and it is preferable to using a plug-in. For larger objects inpainting will help, but if the background is cluttered, you may still have to retouch the resulting image afterwards in Aperture. Inpaint picks the txture to use based on statistics - not based on a semantic analysis of the image.

     

    For a really complicated scene you will have to fall back on Frank Caggiano's initial suggestion - use a full graphics compositing program like Gimp or Photoshop.

     

    Too complicated: let Frodo vanish:

    Original:

    frodoorig37.jpg

    Fixed:

    frodofixed.jpg

    Why is it to complicated? Because Inpaint has no notion of "floor" and "wall" and "table". Here a manual fix would be much better. This method usually works best with outdoor scenes and without objects touching or occluding each other.

     

    Léonie

  • 7. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    stanleyd Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)

    It should also be mentioned that the "clone" approach is used when images in Aperture are shot in RAW and therefore fat as can be… and the pixel rate on my current Nikon of choice is 24.+ Megapixels… that makes possible many things in the edit.

  • 8. Re: how to remove an object/person from photo
    Aye Es Oh Level 2 Level 2 (330 points)

    It generally seems like computer algorithms are good at dealing with objects that are created by deities (sky, mountains, foliage, etc.). But if the object was made by an animal (including humans), it's usually best to edit manually.