... I just read that I should have reported it to my local law enforcement, so I will do that now to report the incident.
Yes, beyond that there is little else you can do.
This is Apple's official word on the subject:
If you have lost or found an Apple product, please contact your local law enforcement agency to report it. Although Apple does not have a process to track or flag lost or stolen product, you can use My Support Profile to find a list of serial numbers for items purchased or registered with your Apple ID.
Consider using this: http://www.stolenlostfound.org/
You might also find the following checklist useful: