Currently Being ModeratedApr 15, 2013 8:14 PM (in response to Lance Mcvickar)
Thanks for the response Lance. Things still aren't working well for me, my receiver is still being shown as a stereo LCD TV for some reason. I'll keep fooling around with it.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 16, 2013 7:50 AM (in response to waldo3125)
Here's an idea, try removing your television from the equation and just have your av amp connected to your Mac. Then if it shows up as the AV amp not LCD TV try plugging the TV while everything is turned on and see what happens there.
I have my macbookpro connected directly to my av amp then the ampt to the TV. My pioneer plasma doesn't have any speakers. Perhaps there is some kind of pass through going on because your tv has speakers, try and set the TV audio in to analog so they are not seen by the amp, I know I'm reaching here but my guess is your tv is taking control of the audio some how.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 21, 2013 9:51 PM (in response to parker612)
I've followed your guide and I'm getting noise out of all my speakers (5.1) when I click on the test buttons in the Audio MIDI Setup. When I'm trying to do a 5.1 sound test from youtube or when I try to play a .MKV file I'm only getting sound out of two speakers, any ideas that can help me?
I used 48000.0 HZ and 8ch-16bit Integer so that I could choose 5.1 in the dropdown meny in Audio MIDI Setup.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 22, 2013 8:02 AM (in response to prismoe)
When I click the test buttons, I too get white noise from each speaker, that is how each speaker is tested to work.
Here is how I have found that surround sound works when using your Mac:
If you connect your Surround Sound System via a MiniDisplay (or Thunderbolt) to HDMI to your Mac, this way lets you select surround sound in the Audio/MIDI Setup and you are able to test each speaker. This connection works great when you're using a video editing application or digital audio workstation that allows surround sound editing and output. It also works with the Mac DVD Player.
If you connect your Surrond Sound System via a toslink cable from the digital audio input on your system to the digital audio output on your Mac,, using a 3.5mm adapter, you won't be able to select surround sound or test your speakers in the Audio/MIDI Setup but you will still get surround sound output from your Mac. This type of connection works with iTunes and Youtube.
I just tested both connection types with a youtube video with 5.1 surround audio and I got surround sound from the toslink connection, but not the MiniDisplay connection.
*I'm not exactly sure why it's like that.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 22, 2013 8:08 AM (in response to prismoe)
VLC should be able to output the surround track of a .mkv file. I have never tried surround off YouTube.
Again the audio midi setup surround settings 5.1 etc are for when you are using apps like logic and Final Cut Pro.
If yo are using VLC selecting the proper audio track and output in vlc's preferences should auto switch your amp to surround mode. I have found that iTunes only does surroundsound if you purchased or rent a movie from iTunes, if it was a video that you converted with handbrake and it has a surround track iTunes still won't play that surround track but VLC will.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 22, 2013 8:14 AM (in response to Lance Mcvickar)
My comments were based on mini display port to hdmi, not toslink, but I just currently connected with toslinki so will do some testing with it when I get some time. And see what the differences are. I guess not all macs are created equal when it comes to surround sound and then you have all the different AV amps as part of the mix.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 22, 2013 10:15 AM (in response to parker612)
I've managed to get 5.1 out of my speakers when watching the .mkv file but I'm still not able to get 5.1 out off the YouTube Video (The exact same video plays just fine in 5.1 when I watch it from my PS3 connected to the same receiver).
Thank you for the guide btw without it I would still have been stuck with my old 2.0 setup.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 22, 2013 1:27 PM (in response to prismoe)
How is your surround sound system connected to your Mac? Did you make sure to select the 720p or 1080p HD option when viewing the YouTube video?
Currently Being ModeratedApr 23, 2013 1:25 PM (in response to parker612)
My Mac is connected via Thunderbolt to hdmi to reciever and yes I'm watching the YouTube video in 720p.
Currently Being ModeratedApr 23, 2013 7:58 PM (in response to prismoe)
You need to connect your surround system with a toslink digital audio optical cable. One end plugs into the headphone jack of your Mac, via a 3.5mm adapter, and the other to the optical input on your system/receiver. You will get surround with this connection type (I've already tested with my own system).
I have this one:
Currently Being ModeratedApr 23, 2013 9:40 PM (in response to parker612)
That seems really strange to me will I be able to have both cables connected at the same time and do I need to do some kind of switching / settings fixing when going from watching a YouTube video to a .mkv file?
Currently Being ModeratedApr 23, 2013 10:28 PM (in response to prismoe)
You can have both cables connected at the same time, you just need to make sure you go into Audio/MIDI Setup and switch from "HDMI" to Built-in Output by right clicking and selecting "output sound from this device."
Also make sure you switch to the proper input on your receiver.
For example, I have both cables connected and when I'm listening to music in iTunes, I use the Built-in Ouput (toslink) and then when I'm editing sound or mixing in Media Composer or Pro Tools, I switch to HDMI (MiniDisplay/Thunderbolt).
Currently Being ModeratedMay 9, 2013 5:29 AM (in response to parker612)
I am connecting a retina MBP to a new Denon receiver as I could not find a replacement for my Saffire interface that died. I want to get 5.1 from FCPX so I can monitor and mix.
I tried the Toslink optical and as Parker says - you can get 5.1 even though it states stereo but the problem is that I find it is not true 5.1. I get all 5 speakers outputting the same audio channel from FCPX.
I will go out and by a HDMI cable and try that. There is a lot of misinofrmation out there because I saw some posts that said retina's HDMI does not output 5.1.
I will check in here later. thanks.
Currently Being ModeratedMay 9, 2013 8:00 AM (in response to Jon Braeley)
It appears that the Retina HDMI port has a problem when attaching an ext. display like my thunderbolt display. When I attached the HDMI cable and turn on the Denon receiver my thunderbolt display goes blank or at least no menus and folders are visible. If I turn off the receiver it goes back to normal.
Here is the thread - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4312536?start=0&tstart=0
Not sure what my options are... not use the HDMI port? But why should I buy a thunderbolt-hdmi adapter when I alraedy have an HDMI port? This a terrible bug.
Currently Being ModeratedMay 13, 2013 12:02 AM (in response to waldo3125)
Hi Waldo, Did you resolved the isse you had because I am in the same situation. I am trying to route the sound to my HT system but the MBP is recognizing only stereo out thru my optical out from headphone jack even if I remove the mini display port cable and try. Can you help me if you fixed it.