Skip navigation
This discussion is archived

getting new MBP within a months time and need help !!!!!!

703 Views 7 Replies Latest reply: Jun 1, 2006 7:22 AM by pisscubes RSS
Glen F. Calculating status...
Currently Being Moderated
May 31, 2006 3:39 PM
I will be ordering a new MBP and I am having some difficulty deciding weather to get the 15" 2.16 with a 100gig 7200rpm HDD and then manually upgrade to 2gigs of ram or get the 17" 2.16 with the 100gig 7200rpm HDD and do the same with the ram. this laptop will be my first laptop and I will be mostly using it for web browsing, email, and some word processing, MP3's. right now I have 2 desktops I use one a windows based for games and a mac mini for mac based desktop needs, both the mini and my windows run off my 17 inch LCD. so I guess my question is the 17" really what I need or will the 15" be good enough and what about the super drives 15" being 4x and the 17" being 8x is there a big difference in burning time for videos.
Home built PC , Mac mini Core Duo, Windows XP Pro
  • mindcrime Level 1 Level 1 (50 points)
    From my perspective, I think the 15.4 MBP would be your best bet. Not sure on the burning time on the 4X compared to 8X but if you do a lot of burning then maybe it's worth getting the 17 inch. Other than that, for general use my 15.4 serves me very well.
    macbook pro, Mac OS X (10.4.6)
  • SJSUengineer Calculating status...
    i have the 17inch and people keep on saying its too big..but i dont really feel like it is...
    Also dont forget the 15 inch MBP also doesnt have that extra 6pin firewire port it only has the 4pin
    MBP 17", Windows XP Pro, AMD X2 4800+
  • pisscubes Calculating status...
    Just a question, but if you are only going to use it for web, email, word processing and MP3's, why don't you save yourself some cash and get the MacBook?
  • Cara Level 3 Level 3 (665 points)
    Since my techie knowledge is pretty limited, I have a question of the yonah vs merom. I hear that yonah is 32 bit and merom is 64 bit. More seems better but if all I do, on average, is use my future MBP for citrix programs (electronic medical records, specifically), websurfing, occasional picture editing with iphoto (cause I'm too cheap to buy better software that I can't count as a tax deduction), preparing powerpoint presentations, and i guess now making little imovies (and I mean very short clips) since I'll have a dvd burner. Phew! run on, would having merom make much difference? And yeah, a macbook would probably serve me well, but I want the 15" screen. I plan on keeping it for 4 years +/- a year depending on how my needs change after residency. I don't do gaming except for weak pogo games every once in a while (cause I need breaks from reading about diseases).

    Is it really worth it for me to wait? at first I waited cause I lacked the cash. Now I have my tax refund to help defray the cost. Oh and then I had a immediate need because my powerbook screen started separating due to trauma I inflicted on it when I was having wireless issues. I found a cheap fix so the urgency from the standpoint of need went away.
    At this point, I would only wait because I intend on having it for a long time and I want the best I can get. Will having a yonah now make it difficult to get software, use future OSX versions, or otherwise difficult to function? I imagine that at least Leopard will work on the current systems otherwise all the folks complaining of "obsolete" machines after the last mini update would burn apple headquarters to the ground. And it really would make no sense to sell machines that can't use software being made ready for release. I actually decided against even going to tiger on this computer because I figured I'd wait for my new computer.

    Why torture myself by waiting if it won't make a lick o difference?
    667 Powerbook G4, Mac OS X (10.3.9), MBP, you will be mine soon!
  • pisscubes Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)
    The Macbook can do video editing. However, if you are doing it on a pro level, I'd certainly say the MBP is what you need.


More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...

Bookmarked By (0)


  • This solved my question - 10 points
  • This helped me - 5 points
This site contains user submitted content, comments and opinions and is for informational purposes only. Apple disclaims any and all liability for the acts, omissions and conduct of any third parties in connection with or related to your use of the site. All postings and use of the content on this site are subject to the Apple Support Communities Terms of Use.