agodfrin

Q: Apple Music replacing my private music with downloads from iTunes store

I just subscribed to Apple Music as a trial. So far everything was going well until ...

 

Over time I have uploaded a number of CDs to my iTunes library on my Mac, and synced on my iPhone.  I was listening to a track while driving (from my iPhone through  the car audio). Then I got home, turned up my Mac and went to listen to the same track ... and it was not the same at all. The one from the CD was a live performance, the new one was a studio recording. Very different.

 

A bit of googling confirmed that this is what Apple Music does: it essentially activates the iTune Match functionality and silently replaces all your songs from whatever is in the iTunes store. One guy on Reddit was complaining that he had lost a vast number of live recordings that way.

 

Note Check your Apple Music library settings - Apple Support actually warns you about that:

 

"if you already have music on your device, you'll be asked if you want to Merge or Replace the music. Choose Merge to add the songs currently on your device to your library.* If you select Replace, the music on your device is replaced with your Apple Music library.'

 

I must have foolishly chosen "Merge" when asked. The problem is that when U turn off "iCloud Music Library", all my private songs disappear. Only the purchases from iTunes Store remain. All my private songs have been uploaded to this "iCloud Music Library". I need to turn the library back to see them again.

 

Thankfully, the majority of my songs match those in the itunes store. Just a small number of tracks have been override by iTunes store versions. The solution seems to be this:

1) force download of all my private music from the iCloud library

2) Disable the iCloud music library

3) delete and reimport the CD with the replaced tracks

4) And of course, cancel my Apple Music subscription.

MacBook Pro, OS X Yosemite (10.10)

Posted on Jul 23, 2015 1:05 AM

Close

Q: Apple Music replacing my private music with downloads from iTunes store

  • All replies
  • Helpful answers

Previous Page 2
  • by wjean11,

    wjean11 wjean11 Jul 6, 2016 6:25 PM in response to agodfrin
    Level 1 (4 points)
    iTunes
    Jul 6, 2016 6:25 PM in response to agodfrin

    I did the exact thing earlier. Canceled Apple Music after all that and switched back to Spotify. I used to like iTunes for its simplicity but it has become increasingly mediocre since the addition of Apple Music. I had over 100GB of my own music to download after canceling.  Music that I added to playlists would dissappear as well. Amongst other dumb setbacks that I never would've expected from Apple based on years passed. Couldn't stand it. Wont' go back or recommend it to anyone that likes music until Apple rectifies this musical aberration.

  • by Dmitriy Malina,

    Dmitriy Malina Dmitriy Malina Jul 22, 2016 12:09 AM in response to agodfrin
    Level 1 (8 points)
    iTunes
    Jul 22, 2016 12:09 AM in response to agodfrin

    This ***** so much. I sold a closet of CDs only to find some of my songs replaced and DRM'd.  This is not obvious and not what I want at all. Essentially I can lose access to my own music:

     

    1. Match with Apple Music

    2. Deleted originals

    3. Apple slave for life

     

    *** AF

Previous Page 2