Lalit Sharma

Q: Apple Watch Heart Rate sensor not giving proper readings during intense exercises like P90x3 and Insanity

I have been using my Apple Watch to track my workout sessions and for past few days I have noted that when ever I am doing intense workouts where there is lot of hand movements like P90x3 or Insanity the Apple watch heart rate sensors gives wrong readings. For example, at the peak of P90x3 workout when I am totally out of breath, the Apple watch heart rate sensor will show heart rate as 62 or 70, but the heart should be in excess of 150+. Today, I tried using a Polar heart rate strap and Polar watch on one wrist and Apple watch on other wrist while doing P90x3 Accelerator workout. Many times it happened that Apple Watch was showing heart rate at around 70-80 while the polar was showing heart rate at 160+.

 

I wear the Apple watch snugly, so I don't thing it is happening because it's loose. However, the watch does move a little on hand while exercising.

Watch Sport 42mm

Posted on May 18, 2015 7:46 PM

Close

Q: Apple Watch Heart Rate sensor not giving proper readings during intense exercises like P90x3 and Insanity

  • All replies
  • Helpful answers

first Previous Page 5 of 5
  • by cheme75,

    cheme75 cheme75 Aug 26, 2016 1:23 PM in response to Evalas
    Level 1 (4 points)
    Aug 26, 2016 1:23 PM in response to Evalas

    I typically see about 12 readings logged per minute or every 5 seconds, not sure if it reads more often and just posts a value. Often during any one of these spans I will see the oddball low reading like chugging along at 100 plus and then 1 or more readings at something like 56 or less, which is physically impossible. I will see a spike up to something like 116 within the multiple readings spanning one minute, this also is highly unlikely - I see the low value a lot more. I frankly think Apple threw the app together as an afterthought. its crazy that apple has not developed some algorithms to filter the data, let us enter our resting heart rate and then toss out any readings below that, do a moving average and compre the readings and toss out the outliers. There are lots of ways the data can be filtered so we're are presented with something useful. They do allow us to manually delete values but it's a royal pain to scroll through the numbers manually. for what it's worth, I hear similar complaints about fit bit's. They use the same green light technology. Slough I also heard the newer models do better. If apple wants the watch to be positioned as a series fitness tool, then they will need to develop some improved algorithms. In my situation, I'm on beta blockers and other meds that limit my heart rate and I also know from multiple tests that my resting heart rate has been fairly consistent at 60-62. I just registered MotiFIT which allows setting custom heart rates so is a lot better for me. only had one workout using it so can't say if it handles the odd readings any better. Hopefully watch os 3 has a major improvement for fitnes.

first Previous Page 5 of 5