Q: Apple Watch Heart Rate sensor not giving proper readings during intense exercises like P90x3 and Insanity
I have been using my Apple Watch to track my workout sessions and for past few days I have noted that when ever I am doing intense workouts where there is lot of hand movements like P90x3 or Insanity the Apple watch heart rate sensors gives wrong readings. For example, at the peak of P90x3 workout when I am totally out of breath, the Apple watch heart rate sensor will show heart rate as 62 or 70, but the heart should be in excess of 150+. Today, I tried using a Polar heart rate strap and Polar watch on one wrist and Apple watch on other wrist while doing P90x3 Accelerator workout. Many times it happened that Apple Watch was showing heart rate at around 70-80 while the polar was showing heart rate at 160+.
I wear the Apple watch snugly, so I don't thing it is happening because it's loose. However, the watch does move a little on hand while exercising.
Watch Sport 42mm
Posted on May 18, 2015 7:46 PM
I've been using my Apple Watch for about 2 weeks. It is not effective as a heart rate monitor for intense exercise. I am an experienced HRM user (mostly Polar) and I too was hoping that the Apple Watch would do away with the need for a chest strap but this is not the case. When I am sitting down or walking around slowly the HRM seems fairly accurate (although sometimes the reading is too low) but if I measure my hear rate during a Crossfit session it is very inaccurate, it particularly seems to miss the near peak heart rates (eg. it will give a reading of around 110 when my actual heart rate is around 150) and sometimes it fails to get any reading at all. I sweat quite heavily and I find that during Crossfit or power yoga the watch ceases to function as an HRM when I am sweating heavily and working out at high intensity. This is very disappointing and I am hopeful that future software upgrades will be able to improve the reliability and accuracy of the HRM. Hopefully the fault is not with the sensor itself but the software. I think Apple will get this right eventually but I think its completely wrong of them to sell a watch with a HRM which doesn't work when you are doing intense exercise because that is an important group of users.
Posted on Jun 9, 2015 10:55 AM