1 2 Previous Next 25 Replies Latest reply: Apr 13, 2008 4:50 PM by 12u34me
REINMIRT Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)
Hey everybody,

I was hoping that people would give some ideas about what display to get for the new mac pro. I am leaning towards a 24" or bigger non-apple display the first time because A) Apples are old technology (specially for gaming) B) they are not the bang for your buck.

Hannspree 28" and Samsung 245bw are 2 options for me right now.

Any comments, recomendations, good/bad experience appreciated. maybe we can create a good display opinion pool here.

M

Powerbook G4, Mac OS X (10.4.11), 1.25GB RAM
  • 1. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    sfaulk Level 1 Level 1 (10 points)
    Based on some very good input I just ordered this one:
    NEC MultiSync LCD2490WUXiSV
    http://www.necdisplay.com/Products/Product/?product=fe2599c6-185f-4177-b12e-5bde 0b8eeaae
  • 2. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Thomas Emmerich Level 4 Level 4 (3,485 points)
    There's a number of recommendations in the Final Cut Pro forums for the Dell 2407WFP. The current version is actually 2407WFP-HC. It has a USB hub and memory card reader built in. If you search the forums for "2407" you'll find the posts. That display was $599 as of 1/30/08 because of a $100 off special but I just looked and its back to $699.

    In the time its taking for my Mac Pro to arrive with the 8800 graphics card I've been waiting for Apple to finally update their displays. Barring that, I may go for the Dell.
  • 3. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    AppleNewton Level 2 Level 2 (185 points)
    i wouldnt hold your breath for a new apple display, they were built pretty future proof and are still better than a lot of newer and current displays out there.
    even the good ones still have drawbacks and i wouldnt just pick up a bang for your buck monitor either, they also contain some problems.

    for one, that "Hannspree 28inch", which i take it is really the Hanns-G 28" monitor, avoid that like the plague!
    Might have a nice price tag, but its not even worth that much.
    you can see each backlight lamp on the four sides of the display, and the center is completely dead darker then that outer radius around it, even calibrating it or using a color matching profile in the SysPref does nothing to give it a good quality, uneven backlighting horrible for graphics/gaming/profressional work.
    not to mentionsome weird "overscan" issue. like if youre viewing variants of greys, yellows or blue backgrounds (perfect example; dashboard, the greyish overlay you could see interference like diagonal lines) it has noticeable diagonal scan lines on macpros (my new acd 30" does not), so it does not have accurate pixel matching for high end graphics cards.

    sorry for that rant but i just returned mine the other day because though it was a nice display it just lacked quality.

    id prefer,m hate to say, the Dell 24" or perhaps even this one looks and appears to be not bad and a good price for a 24"
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824255001
    westinghouse is becoming quite a good display manufacture lately.


    if not HP and viewsonic are also good backup options with consumer friendly prices....they have a wide variety of professional grade displays without the premium

    here are some 24" displays:
    http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&N=2010190020+130982132 8&name=24%22

    and some larger displays:
    (note: displays over 24-26" do not accurately display resolutions unless its an oddball type...the max resolution for a 24" display will be the same on a 26"-28" display, fyi ~ ie; Hanns-g)

    26: http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&N=2010190020+130982386 7&name=26%22

    27: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824001233

    28: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824116084

    30: http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&N=2010190020+130982515 1&name=30%22


    has a lot of competitive pricing and usually most dsplays by Samsung are a great deal regardless of size.

    goodluck! hope that helped!
  • 4. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    solsun Level 3 Level 3 (515 points)
    So what is "Old technology" about Apple's Cinema display's? I only ask because I am considering purchasing the 30" to replace my G4 generation 17" and 20".

    I already have an external iSight cam, and I don't see the 30" going LED anytime soon, so what else is considered "old" about Apple's specs?
  • 5. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Thomas Emmerich Level 4 Level 4 (3,485 points)
    The current Cinema Displays were introduced in 2004. Since then the only changes have been price drops and LCD panel changes. The external case design is much the same.

    The last change was in April 2007 when the prices were dropped without any change in specs.
    The previous change to that was in Aug 2006 when the prices were dropped and the LCD specs were improved. That's 1.5 years since the specs were changed which is a long time in the technology world.
  • 6. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    dosers Level 2 Level 2 (390 points)
    There is nothing bad about the Apple Displays.
    They look great, are stylish. They ARE more expensive than other brands - so there you go.
    But unless you 'need' HDMI or multiple inputs, they are just fine.
    I have the 30 inch Apple and I love it - I would buy the same thing again today if I had the choice. It's very good quality, great colour consistency, big. I am not looking for 2 ms faster response for gaming, but overall quality. Again, they are not really price competitive, but it's worth it to me.

    Check one out in teh Apple store!

    D
  • 7. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Thomas Emmerich Level 4 Level 4 (3,485 points)
    I've been looking at just about every 24" display available over the last couple of weeks. Not withstanding the LCD panel inside, the Apple case design is the least flimsy (actually not flimsy at all). Most of the others I've seen the case is plastic and they have a "cheap" feel to them. The Apple display feels solid as a rock.
  • 8. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    BillF Level 3 Level 3 (640 points)
    I bought a Westinghouse 24 inch monitor that has VGA and HDMI. It is somewhat interesting because I can run video out to the unit using the HDMI, or I can use the DVI to HDMI from the Mac Pro. I bought this unit as a low cost holdover in case Apple had come out with new monitors at Macworld. Turned out they did not do any monitor upgrades yet, so I wound up keeping the Westinghouse. I really like the aluminum look of the Apple Monitor, however, I also paid half of what I would have paid for an Apple monitor. The response time of this monitor is really good, and I can also plug in a Playstation, or an HD-DVD player to the HDMI and enjoy HDTV. Good luck in your choices.
  • 9. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Yonidass Level 1 Level 1 (5 points)
    I think it really depends on what you're using it for. If gaming and/or movies are a high priority, then response time is important. If you work with graphics then color is important. True color representation is generally what's going to cost you, if I'm not mistaken. I bought a Samsung 226BW not long ago and, as I knew beforehand, the color was pretty bad from a professional point of view. Very heavy on the blues, and I haven't been able to tweak it to look nearly as good as my PowerBook's colors (a 3 year old laptop monitor). But I don't work with graphics and other than the color, which I no longer notice, it's a good looking monitor and it was cheap. So decide what's important and do your research. There are plenty of tests done on popular monitors.
  • 10. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Some Dude Level 1 Level 1 (55 points)
    I splurged a couple months ago and bought 3 of the Dell UltraSharp 2407WFP-HC 24-inch Widescreen monitors. They list at 699 a piece, you can get Dell to drop the price if you buy more than one. I normally don't like Dell, but these things have amazing picture quality.

    I know it's a bit extreme, but I love having a center screen and 2 flanking screens across my desk, angled inward. Sometimes I'll watch TV on the right hand screen, use the center one for my work PC(s) (via KVM switch), and use the left one for my old Sawtooth G3. When I get my new MacPro (on order now), I will use the DVI inputs of course on all 3 from the new Mac, and have a 3-wide extended desktop for my Mac - brought to you of course by the use of 2 8800GT cards.

    I actually thought about going with 2 of the 30 inch apple screens, but really wanted to have 3 monitors, with one dead center and 2 flanking. The fact that my KVM switch for my servers would not display correctly on the 30 inch apple screen put the nail in the coffin of that idea as well.

    Just some thoughts FWIW.
  • 11. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    Seaking406 Level 1 Level 1 (20 points)
    Just check on their site, Dell Canada online has the 2407WFP-HC for sale for the $599 ($100 reduction in price)

    I'll be purchasing one for the PC and will be able to compare it to the 23-inch Apple Cinema HD I have hooked to the MacPro..

    Cheers
  • 12. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    houseofschwartz Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)
    I also hate to say it, but I have a Dell 24" monitor. I replaced an Apple Cinema Display that lasted about 5 years. When I bout the Dell, the Apple 24" was about $300 more. The Apple monitor is prettier, but I'd rather spend that 300 elsewhere. And I actually use the card readers on the monitor quite a bit. And all and all, its not a bad looking monitor.
  • 13. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    apeguero Level 1 Level 1 (0 points)
    I have the Gateway XHD3000. It's a $1700.00 30" LCD with a DVI, VGA, HDMI, Component, Composite, S-Video, detachable speaker bars with dual headphone input, 6 USB ports, remote control, picture in picture, and a big hunking power supply

    It's color display is around 76%, not quite as accurate as the Apple Cinema Display but the response time is really quick and the scaling engine is pretty good. Basically, it does an excellent job at displaying anything less than 2560x1600 resolution at full screen.

    I spend my typical work day with my Mac Pro on DVI and my VGA work laptop on the PIP. I'll also switch the PIP input to HDMI while on my Mac so I can catch a little bit of DirecTV HD shows.

    I just couldn't find another monitor to meet my needs. The new Dell 3008 HC monitor is close but the XHD3000 offers more of the options I was looking for, mainly the built in speakers and remote control.

    Not trying to convince you to buy the Gateway but I have to say that other than an occassional 1 second blackout (while it adjust to DVI input), it's a pretty good monitor an has made me happy. The Blackout issue I think is related to the imaging engine adjusting to the DVI port as it doesn't happen anywhere else and only occurs after I switch to DVI. I also heard in other sites that it's a timing issue that could be remedied by making timing adjustments in your video card BIOS. Don't ask me how this is done because I have the ATI X1900XT on my Mac Pro and I don't know where that is adjusted. Good luck.
  • 14. Re: Any Monitor suggestions for the new mac pro w 8800GT?
    John Phillips10 Level 1 Level 1 (45 points)
    Can US residents buy from Dell Canada? I couldn't figure how to grab a 2407 at $599

    Thanks

    John
1 2 Previous Next