AT&T Family Plan for iPhone and non-iPhone

I was a little surprised to hear this:

It costs $39.99 for the entry-level individual plan for a non-iPhone.
It costs $59.99 for the entry-level individual plan for an iPhone.
It costs $109.99 for the entry-level family plan where you have one iPhone, whether or not your second phone is an iPhone or not.

(By contrast, starting with the 3rd line, additional iPhone lines are $29.99 each BUT additional non-iPhone lines are $9.99 each.)

What is my incentive to add a second non-iPhone to the family plan, rather than just opening a separate AT&T account for less? In fact, other than the free minutes between AT&T lines (certainly a consideration), why not just open the 2nd account with Verizon?

Is this just a bad corporate policy, or am I missing something?





PB G4 1.67 Mac OS X (10.4.2)

PB G4 1.67, Mac OS X (10.4.2)

Posted on Jul 2, 2007 2:34 PM

Reply
15 replies

Jul 2, 2007 2:43 PM in response to maxwell

My DH had an individual account with AT&T, which we converted to a Family Plan to add the iPhone (mine, all mine... my precious...). We didn't initially switch our kids phone over to AT&T. We came home and did a little cypherin' and placed a call to Verizon. The cheapest plan they had was $40 a month. My kids hardly ever use their phone (a rarity I know) so that seemed kinda steep. After doing the math it turns out that it was cheaper to pay the penalty, buy them a Razor and put them on AT&T for $10 a month.

Jul 2, 2007 5:55 PM in response to maxwell

THe family plan has DOUBLE the minutes. Or nearly double. I think the single plan is 350-400 minutes and the family plan starts at 700minutes. If you compare oranges to oranges, and compare a single plan for 700 minutes and a family plan for 700minutes, it is only $10 for the second phone on the family plan with no iphone. For my family of 4 phones, I changed over to an iphone, and it truly was only $20 more for the iphone per month. Now I have 2 teens and we use the 700minutes, so for us, 3 more phones at 9.99 a piece is a steal.

Jul 2, 2007 6:03 PM in response to nlkflint

Thanks for the post, but I'm not sure I understand or agree with it. I have an iPhone and a non-iPhone. Thus, I have two choices. My first choice is a Family Plan, which costs $109 and gives me 700 total minutes for both phones. My second choice is one individual iPhone plan and one individual non-iPhone plan, which costs me $99 total ($59.99 + $39.99) and gives me 900 total minutes for both phones. Thus, the iPhone Family Plan makes no sense if you have a non-iPhone in the deal b/c AT&T won't give you a discount to account for the non-iPhone.

(I believe the $9.99 for the non-iPhone only starts on the 3rd line, not the 2nd).

Jul 2, 2007 11:41 PM in response to maxwell

I have an iPhone and my wife has a Razr.

We have the Family Talk Nation 1400 minutes plan for $89.99 a month plus $20 a month for the iPhone data plan. We could have gone cheaper with the 700 minutes plan for $69.99 or the 550 minutes plan for $59.99.

So, the cheapest family plan for 1 iphone, 1 non-iphone, is $79.99 (includes data for iPhone).

That is still not too bad.

BTW, I was told by AT&T to do this when activating my iPhone but wanting a family plan.

1) Activate the iPhone via iTunes, pick a single user plan.
2) Once iPhone is operational, call AT&T sales, and change your plan to a family talk plan, order a non-iphone phone and add $20 iphone data plan.

This is what I did and all is good. You basically can't do it online if you have the iPhone already in hand.

Jul 3, 2007 2:47 AM in response to setec

If you go to the AT&T website, and look up the plans, it states there:

Get iPhone for every member in the family. Plans start at $109.99 for two iPhone lines and include Visual Voicemail and Unlimited Data—email and web—and 200 SMS text messages (you can add more text messages for a little more a month). Additional iPhone lines (up to 3 more) are $29.99 each. Additional non-iPhone lines are $9.99 each.

So it looks like the Family Plan should cover 2 iPhones. If you only got one, and are looking at staying with only one iPhone, stay wtih your current family plan and add a data plan.


Windows XP

Jul 4, 2007 9:33 AM in response to maxwell

BTW - it works just fine to go into AT&T, switch (and get a cheap phone), and then buy the iPhone right away and port the number over to that. It's what I did, and I got a plan that's better for me that way.

I recommend visiting an AT&T store until you're happy with your plan, then using iTunes to swap the one line to iPhone which will add another $20 to your plan, and then you're good to go.

Good luck!
Aym

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

AT&T Family Plan for iPhone and non-iPhone

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.