My favorite iPhone case so far

Question

Level 1

91 points

My favorite iPhone case so far

so Ive tried 4 different cases for my iPhone so far, and the one I like the best by far is the Case-mate signature leather case designed exclusively for the iPhone. I picked it up at my local AT&T store. The reason I like it is its still thin enough for your pocket, it looks like it would REALLY protect the phone in case of an accidental drop, it has an optional belt clip (sticks out from your belt a little too far, but still, better then others), it comes with a very good screen protector (unfortunately it has mild adhesive on it, i removed it and there was NO residue) and it works great with the touchscreen. The edges around the screen are slightly raised, meaning that any drop onto a flat surface will NOT hit the screen any way possible. Its durable, classy looking, and the iPhone doesnt try to jump out of your hand when holding it (ok Apple, dont you think instead of making a nice, slick, smooth device, perhaps put ridges or rubber on it for better grip? I mean really, holding the iphone without a case is like trying to hold an ice cube with your hand wrapped in plastic wrap).

As far as the others Ive tried, I used the suggestion to use the cloth carry case that comes with the 5G iPods, and while it fits, its not snug and slides out too easy. I got the rubber one with the headset holder on the back.. too bulky and I dont always need the headset holder. Made it rough to fit in the pocket. And then I got the regular leather pouch. Holds it nicely, but getting it out (and in without hitting buttons) is a pain and I feel like I might damage the iPhone from all the pushing on it to get it out of the case.

So, the case-mate Signature Leather Case as seen here http://www.iprong.com/article.php?id=2799 gets my vote so far for best case.

PC, Windows Vista

Posted on Jul 5, 2007 1:25 PM

Reply

Answer 1

mwhitted

Level 1

50 points

Jul 5, 2007 3:05 PM in response to markdr

I have the perforated leather version on order. Thanks for the review!

Reply

Answer 2

markdr Author

Level 1

91 points

Jul 5, 2007 3:18 PM in response to mwhitted

Thats a nice one too. I didnt see the other available options, the phantom black was the only one they had at the store.
You should be very happy with this case. I am. I feel like I have successfully protected the iPhone without having to cover up or limit its features (and take it out of a darn case for every call I get or every time I want to look at the screen)...

Reply

Answer 3

dianah

Level 1

0 points

Jul 5, 2007 5:30 PM in response to markdr

What about how far it sticks out from your waist when it's on your belt? Does it really get in the way of how you move, like with your arm rubbing against it, etc? I like the way the case looks, but am worried about constantly bumping it with my arm. I like the closer to the body types of clips.

Reply

Answer 4

Fredrrr

Level 2

156 points

Jul 5, 2007 5:32 PM in response to dianah

I like that one as well (so far of course). Not bulky and comes with a screen protector.

Reply

Answer 5

icar

Level 1

0 points

Jul 5, 2007 6:10 PM in response to markdr

this is the one I ordered, it's a belt clip holster. the clip is not to bulky.
very inexpensive too..I figured if I don't like it,,it was only 8 bucks.
It comes in white also...

http://item.express.ebay.com/FOR-APPLE-IPHONE-CELL-PHONE-BLACK-HOLSTER-CASE-4-8G B_W0QQitemZ110144761648QQihZ001QQtrZexpQQcmdZExpressItem

Reply

Answer 6

Jul 5, 2007 9:44 PM in response to icar

I also had the case mate leather case from the AT&T store, and I hate how far it stick out. I am a big guy and don't need anything else sticking out from my waist area. I just picked up a universal pouch from Walmart for $8.00 that should hold me over for a while. For my Blackberry I got a clip from Sedio that I loved. I am waiting for them to come out with something. For the person who ordered the Ebay belt holster can you post your results?

Reply

Answer 7

Jul 5, 2007 11:08 PM in response to markdr

my husband bought me a silicone double pack when he bought me the iphone. and i hate them...

i went on to casemate and bought myself one of the leather ones the same day... it should be here tomorrow!!

glad to hear a good review on it! now i can't wait to get it!

Reply

Answer 8

markdr Author

Level 1

91 points

Jul 6, 2007 8:44 PM in response to dianah

sorry its a bit late of a reply... I keep the iPhone in my pocket so was looking for a thin, sturdy case. This case fit that bill perfectly. As far as does it stick out too far? Well, I dont like anything on my belt at all, but to be honest, it does stick out. It doesnt hit when you swing your arms, but the top portion of it does not rest firmly against your hip. I can see it getting hit going through a doorway or whatever.
Hope that helps. I still would take it over the others. The plain leather holster you can buy is not worth it for sure. Hard to get out, and the clip is not secure on your waist. Mine slid off several times getting in and out of my car seat.

Reply

Answer 9

Jul 6, 2007 9:28 PM in response to coopsgrl98

I just got the Leather Prestige case from Pocket Solutions. I wear mine on my belt and this is perfect. It is high quality, fits snugly and allows you to plug in the headphones while it is in the case. You will not have access to the dock port on the bottom. It you need to use the volume buttons you have to open the top flap only.

http://www.thepocketsolution.com/PSI-35167.html

Reply

Answer 10

Jul 6, 2007 10:02 PM in response to markdr

I have the Casemate and love it. Using it without the clip. All together, still a smaller profile than my (ex) Treo.

Reply

Answer 11

corrgan

Level 1

15 points

Jul 6, 2007 10:13 PM in response to LarsThorwald

I have the same case as the first post, and it's great. I don't think it sticks out too far, but then again, I'm used to a Treo on my hip. It's great, and the Apple Store employees loved it!

Reply

Answer 12

yosappy

Level 1

10 points

Jul 6, 2007 11:03 PM in response to markdr

I have to totally disagree with you. I also bought the Case-mate from the AT&T Store. It has 2 terrible problems. 1. The top of the case partially covers the ear-piece on the front of the phone. 2. The stupid sticky protective shield already had fingerprints on it when I opened it up and there is only one in the package. When I tried to clean it, it just totally grabbed more lint and dirt so now it is useless. So, I plan to return mine and I bought the new Contour Case that is on the Apple Store web site. I have that case for my iPod and I really love it because it is clear and it protects well.

Reply

Answer 13

ibroker

Level 1

74 points

Jul 6, 2007 11:04 PM in response to markdr

Whatever you guys do I don't suggest that all clear plastic one. I thought it was pretty cool looking & would show off the look of the iPhone the best but it was sooooo flimsy & if the phone fell from no more than 2 feet it would have shattered. I took it back & got the case mate as well & am much happier.

Reply

Answer 14

Jul 6, 2007 11:24 PM in response to markdr

Okay I am a total girly girl so this was hard for me.. I did order the plastic clear case because I have a woman who does my Ipod and My razor cases is gorgeous lead crystal custom designs and she is working on one for my Iphone, and since the aluminum cases are not out yet the plastic is all we have to work with..... so UNTIL then.

I can't see doing silicone.. its not me.. I was at Books A million today and found the PERFECT case.. it has a Brighton look, very elegant with a small silver pen and a small handle to clip on a bag.. it comes in black or brown leather.. but very feminine... it fits the Iphone very well

I also went on ebay to order a few.. you can't beat the prices.. I have dealt with several of those Hong Kong manufacturers and so far have been happy with the results (always a risk when you order overseas)

I do find it funny they missed the mark on this.. NO one has even simple cases.. thats when buyers get the fever they want new things for the new toy.. should have realized a few cases that are not so "masculine" or cheap looking.

Reply

Answer 15

RossCB

Level 1

5 points

Jul 7, 2007 7:01 AM in response to smartblond

I hated the Casemate, however i loved the protective screen cover it had, better than any other i have seen, however i felt like the case was made from hard Foam, wrapped in leather, and felt it may break, or even snap. I love the Incase, i think it provides good support, ( i use it with the case-mate screen protector, and it provides incredible amount of grip with out bulk. Great case, always looking for one more perfect however.... I have actually decided i dont want to constantly use a case, so i think im going to use it as necessary, i just love the skinny form factor of the iPhone with out any case. However i do love protection, but i feel the phone is solidly build, and i have heard.

Reply