eric,
A definitive test for troubleshooting a battery issue is to swap batteries with another Pismo or Lombard, but one may not be available.
Regardless of whether you have a bad battery and/or failed charging circuits, your Pismo should still sleep as long as the power adapter is connected with software and/or a corrupted power manager being the most common issue.
Also, if you are using the power manager reset button on the back panel to restart (or reset the power manager), it will require the reset of time/date.
I would try your troubleshooting in this manner:
1. Keep the power adapter connected at all times plus disconnect ALL peripherals.
2. Pull out the main battery a few inches so it is not engaged.
3. From a shut down state, reset the power manager:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=14449
4. Start up and reset the time/date.
5. Now test if your Pismo will sleep/wake normally.
You can also test your PRAM battery (the internal rechargeable backup battery), but also read how this battery works vs. a desktop PRAM battery:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=30580
You can then insert the main battery and see if it is recognized. I suspect you have a failing battery •IF• the Pismo will occasionally see and charge the battery.
We can do additional testing based on your results.
Message was edited by: jpl