VHS to DV tapes...problem with new Sony camcorders

I had a nice Sony miniDV camcorder, the DCR HC 30. Worked great to record almost all of my VHS tapes to DV, which I am using to created my iMovies. The camcorder worked fine in this mode. It then had a problem with regular recording, capturing the audio, but not video. Known problem to Sony, who repaired the camcorder at no cost. It worked great again, but the last time I went to record from my VHS tape, it worked for an hour, and then the touch-screen menu failed to respond to touch. (Another story).

I also have a newer Sony camcorder, the DCR HC 26. Connected it to the VCR to record from the VHS tape. I then discovered that this camcorder will allow recording FROM the camcorder TO the VCR with the AV connector, but if I want to record FROM the VCR, it will only work using the DV connector into an iLink port (Firewire).

I went to the 'Sony Style' store (yes,Palo Alto has everything!) and the guy first insisted it could be done with the new HC 38 and 48, but after he actually read the manuals, it was the same as the HC26: must have a Firewire port on the VCR. How dumb is that? How many of us have all these old VHS tapes, probably old VCRs too, and none of the old ones will have FireWire ports!
I have always recommended copying VHS footage to DV tapes, and now I am not going to be able to do that unless I get a converter. Seems a bit expensive for just the few VHS tapes that I forgot to convert previously.

I tried to see if the HC 30 can be repaired again....Sony wants $211 just to check it out. I can buy a new camcorder for $320 so it doesn't seem worth it unless I can connect the touch-screen failure with the problem with video recording that was supposedly corrected.

May have to get a converter.....last resort is another old camcorder Sony TRV something. It is on its last legs, but maybe it could work for a few hours more!

Wanted to let it be known that direct recording from an old VCR to new Sony miniDV cannot be done.

iMac FP 1GHz 80GB 1.25RAM, ext drives: Maxtor, Lacie, Mac OS X (10.4.9), iPhoto6.0.6, iTunes7.1.1, iMovie6.0.3, iDVD6.0.3

Posted on Jul 17, 2007 5:18 PM

Reply
10 replies

Jul 18, 2007 11:08 AM in response to Beverly Maneatis

I agree, Beverly.

Unfortunately, Sony is not in the software business so they could care less if their cameras work with imovie! And that is too bad because I truly love all of my Sony cameras.

I actually have a G5 with iLife 04, QT 6.5.2 and Panther set up to do all of my work videos. I use a DCR-TRV310 NTSC (and I have a brand new one in the box in case this one blows) or the Sony DCR-TRV260 and a lifetime supply of HI-8 video tapes.

Hey-if it ain't broke....

LOL! Sue

My DCR-TRV330 bit the dust in the spring....rest his little shutter....

Jul 18, 2007 5:37 PM in response to tilman

Hi tilman - yes - bottom line is not to discard an old vidcam with analogue-in when buying its 'higher-speced(?!) replacement - although that doesn't help Beverly with her problem.
There must be large numbers of second-hand cams with that function being sold as people rush to buy DVD vidcams etc, so it will be worth looking out for a good cheap one.
It seems that soon the only mini-DV cams will be higher-end models, some of which, being larger, have much reduced portability. Ah! Progress!
User uploaded file

Jul 18, 2007 6:03 PM in response to catspaw

Yeah, I got out my old heavy Sony TRV-10 and finally remembered which button to hold down with the 'Rec' and it is recording....I hope!

It looks fine, and I think it should be ok. Thank goodness I hadn't sold or given this camcorder away! I was thinking about getting rid of it when I came across it while putting things away in a cabinet in our family room.

I have only about 5 or 6 VHS tapes that I forgot about when I copied the others, so this shouldn't take too long. Then, "just in case" I will keep this TRV camcorder!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

VHS to DV tapes...problem with new Sony camcorders

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.