Have to agree that while I love the iPhone, don't mind AT&T, am fine with it locked down and I never plan on hacking, when it comes to ringtones I feel Apple is just asking too much. Ok, I know the record industry won a court case saying a ringtone is a new work of art different from the original (which I disagree with) which gives them the law on their side saying they can charge for it (record industry wanted it this way as the artist doesn't get money from ringtone sales since they are considered a different work of art). But if I can make an MP3 myself (record my wife talking or record an old phone) then put it in iTunes and put it in my iPod player, why can I not put it as a ringtone since I legally own it. I made it thus not even the record industry can say I am stealing a piece of their work. On every phone that I owned since they had custom ringtones I have been able to put my own ringtones in free of charge (without hacking). I have always had recordings of my wife saying "Hey, sexy, your phone is ringing" or something similar. I hate that I cannot now when I have what I feel the best phone out right now.
Sorry Apple, I am on your side with all the bad PR coming your way about everything else, but Ringtones, come on. Go ahead and charge if iTunes knows it is your format and bought from your store thus you know the ringtone technically is the record guys art thus you have to charge to keep them happy, but if it is an MP3, technically you have no way of knowing if it is something you can charge for so just let it be free. You will make less money yes but there are plenty of non computer folks that just use iTunes and all thier stuff is from you and they will pay for ringtones.
Also, my wife (and I) was upset that we own a CD and I ripped it to MP3 and we own the songs legally, and she wanted a ringtone of one of the songs. Went to iTunes and saw I can make one (icon) but I couldn't click it because I would have to first buy the track from you (though I already have my copy) before I can opt to buy again a ringtone. You try to claim the price is .99 for a ringtone, but for everybody that had music before you guys, ringtones actually cost $2 if we want anything we
already own.