New iskin evo4 Duo for Ipod classic

i still use the old iskin evo 3 case on my ipod classic, to eradicate the problem of the click wheel not responding cut out the rubber part of the click wheel to be able to use it again.

those new iskin evo 4 cases don't look nice at all i don't like the grey parts with the dull colours, it just don't match, i won't be wasting money on a new case for my ipod as they are too expensive anyway.

edit: here is a video i did earlier when i cut out the click wheel part, hopefully it will show you what i mean.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi58f-0GR14

Message was edited by: jalaneme

A poster at iLounge has already received and reviewed his iSkin evo4. Here's his review:

iSkin evo4 Crimson Review

http://forums.ilounge.com/showpost.php?p=1170126&postcount=14

urgh, those pictures are horible, and the click wheel colour is horid too.

Personally I like the Jam Jackets. I used one on my 1st Gen Nano and it protected it from smudge/scratches but also served as a cushion the few times its fallen. I plan to buy the new one made for Classic when I get my Classic iPod.

Details: http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8577649&type=product&id=1190411436 530

The click wheel is semi-transparent, is the silicone. I think looks great, of course with silver iPod. I have the black one and maybe the click wheel will look ugly with that cases. I thought that evo4 was more bulky. What i don't like is the back.
Still i don't know what case buying for my iPod.

i have a black ipod classic, the evo case wouldn't go with my ipod at all.

Anyone tried http://ifrogz.com/products.php?cat=337?

Stay away from the iSkins. The silicon over the clickwheel stretches out quickly and behaves like a loose condom. The inconsistent sensitivity then renders the wheel almost unusable. iSkin told me today that I need to "massage" the whole silicone piece and that the problem is with the individual user and iPod; "it is not a manufacturing defect". I guess that is technically true since it is iSkin's design defect that is the problem. Oh, and the "new" evo3 for the classic has the exact same thin silicon membrane, so it is not an alternative. If the product shortcomings weren't enough, the poor and indifferent response of their customer service is enough to pass them up for consideration, permanently.

Yes I just recently got the Iskin claro which has a similar silicone case for my ipod classic 80gb and am finding that scrolling is difficult if not impossible, perhaps Apple will create a scrol sensitivty in the settings menu to remedy the problem for after market accesories such as this

Shut up and quit complaining