Wire Removal

Got a problem that I guess I created myself. I'm editing a dance concert in which one of the main characters flies at the end. Well, the producer wants the wires taken out because with all the other cool effects I did in the video they don't fit. Darn my mad skills.

Anyway, I need to take a the wires out and am having a very hard time. ANy ideas?

Posted on Nov 5, 2005 9:54 AM

Reply
9 replies

Nov 6, 2005 11:34 PM in response to Benjamin Blue

I have no tricks - Keyframing a shape (or mask shape) is all I can say without knowing more about the shots you are dealing with. If it is a lock off, you can use a key and a mask (to limit the key area) to show thru to a clean frame (when there is no wire in it - this is sometimes as simple as the same shot a couple of frames behind/ahead).

Patrick

Nov 7, 2005 10:57 AM in response to Patrick Sheffield

I don't have After Effects and can't afford it for this one job. I've been trying to just do a mask over the wires but it's taking forever.< </div>

Without the proper tools, wire removal is a frame-by-frame slog. There are no shortcuts that you will find acceptable, just some workarounds that leave tracks. Most wire removals are simple PS-like clone stamps that pick up a few pixels next to the wire and just move them so they cover the wire. Easy until you start dealing with image smear and bad lighting that glints off the wires and leaves video artifacts in preceding frames. Oh, so tedious.

If you're getting paid for the job, buy After Effects. You will be REALLY glad you did.
If you're getting paid for the job but don't want to invest in AE, find someone locally who has After Effects. You will be very glad you brought them into the project.
Try David Slater's Web site to see if anyone has introduced cheap plugs for wire removal for FCP. Digital Heaven might have one and it will only be $10.00.
If you're NOT getting paid for the job, explain the amount of work involved and give the producer some choices: Ask him/her to pay for the appropriate effects tools or have it restaged and reshot properly. There are wire rigs that are all but invisible, why weren't they in use?

JMO: Your client is asking w-a-y too much of you.

bogiesan

Nov 7, 2005 12:32 PM in response to Benjamin Blue

One last tip that might work - if they were filmed against some color, you can use a chroma key and use matte magic to narrow the matte (to close off the area where the wire is, then apply a second matte magic to broaden it again so the person isn't so constricted. This has the effect of removing small single/double pixel holes in the mask. Then you need to be laying this over a clean frame of the background.

Patrick

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Wire Removal

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.