2714 Views 11 Replies Latest reply: Apr 3, 2008 3:45 PM by Walter Kilbourne
I am happy to report that an extremely helpful gentleman at AppleCare solved this problem for me. It is a known issue, though I don't know that they know exactly what is causing it. Assuming you are using Leopard, simply do an archive and install of the operating system. Then do the updates. For me, after that, problem solved. Maybe it had something to do with the interaction of the firmware and the updates or something. Best of luck.
This topic is appearing throughout Apple's discussion boards and other Mac discussion boards.
I have been experiencing the same problems with my superdrive on my Mac Pro after installing Leopard. I have tried all the recommended fixes:
1. change system prefs for CD and DVD to open in finder.
2. zap the PRAM, and
3 clean the superdrive lens with an CD lens cleaner.
All these fixes have not corrected the problems, thus one would suspect a hardware problem. This conclusion is also reinforced by the fact that I have recently used a Macbook Pro, Intel iMac, and a MDD DP G4, all with Leopard installed, and they all can recognize blank CDRs and DVDR. I also contacted an local Apple repair tech and he did state that it is probably is a defective superdrive.
"NOW HERE IS THE CATCHER" -When I boot up Window's XP via Boot Camp on the suspect Mac Pro, the superdrive behaves properly and it will recognize and burn a blank CDR. These observations can only point to towards an OS problem with specific hardware and not totally an hardware failure.
For all those having CDR/DVDR recognition problems please do the following to help resolve this problem:
- boot up Boot Camp, if you have it installed,
- see if Windows can recognize and burn a CDR/DVDR, and
- report your findings to Apple and others.
Hopefully someone at Apple will notice this problem.
I too, have experienced this problem. 4 month iMac with Tiger, upgraded to Leopard. 4 folks at AppleCare and one at the Genius Bar diagnosed it as a bad superdrive. I had An Apple tech replace the drive. On reassembly and reboot, the same problem persisted: it would read burned dvd/cd's, but not recognize blanks. They then simply booted the box off of their network drive and suddenly, the drive could recognize and burn blank cd's. Their solution: archive and reinstall. I queried that since a downloaded update caused the problem, how would re-downloading updates solve the problem (as opposed to reproducing it); they responded: we don't know, it just seems to work. I haven't had the chance to try it yet as I need the box to be functional this week for work, but next Sat I will take the plunge. Fortunately, I have all my data and install-images on a spare drive, but come on Apple; trash and reinstall? What is this, Windows?
I have the same difficulties with CD and DVD. The discs refuse to mount on the finder. They are identified discs ready to burn. This problem, undoubtedly, appeared after an update. I wish and hope that APPLE correct this system error quickly, or that it indicates the procedure to us.
I fear that the mac-users are ineffective.
Seeing this thread, I'm not alone. I did an archive and Install of Leopard, and now the Optiarc drive in my April 2007 MacPro octo sporadically will not mount and read a previously burned DVD and treats it as a blank disk, launching Toast. These unreadable disks will usually mount in an old external firewire drive. I called AppleCare, and they are supposed to be sending me a replacement drive. I'm hoping it isn't another Optiarc.
AppleCare sent me another Optiarc 7170 to replace the one in my MacPro Octo (April 07) that wouldn't read older DVDs that I had burned to archive my photos. It doesn't seem to be much better than the original one. I inserted one disk and the Optiarc ejected it every time. However, the same disk mounted with no problem in the Matshita drive in my MacBook Pro, copied to the hard drive, and copied to from the hard drive back to a blank DVD. That's how I finally got my files into the MacPro, a much more expensive machine than the MacBook Pro. Why can't Apple supply an optical drive in its top of the line computer that is at least as good as the one in its laptops?
I phoned AppleCare today to see if they would replace the Optiarc with some other brand of optical drive. To recap, the Optiarc ejects a DVD without mounting it, while the Matshita in my MacBook Pro reads that disk just fine, as does the Matshita in my husband's iMac. After more than an hour on the phone with an AppleCare rep and a supervisor the response was that the DVD drive was only required to read commercial DVDs not customer-burned DVDs, and that Apple would not replace the Optiarc with another brand of drive. The rationale—the MacPro was designed to use the Optiarc, and "there is no guarantee" that another brand of drive would read my homeburned disks. Everything from the fact that I burned the disk using Toast, and used DVD-R media was used to support the notion that Apple has no responsibility to provide me with a DVD drive that performs at least as well as the ones in the MacBook Pro and the iMac. I have been an Apple customer for 20 years, have bought numerous Macs, and this is the worst AppleCare experience I have ever had.
Posting here because this is the closest to my issue.
My Optiarc 7170 problem is that it refuses to read any DVD made by Microsoft. Period. It will read Mac DVDs, blank DVDs, DVDs made by other PC manufacturers, but nothing by Micrsoft. I've tried Vista, XP, Halo 2, Streets and Trips, you name it, it won't read it. Maybe this isn't surprising, but if I dupe the Microsoft disk using my son's iMac, the duped DVD will read. Needless to say, I'd like to not have to do that.
Oh, and the same behavior occurs when I'm running Windows under Bootcamp. My firmware is 1.N7. I'd love to have a solution to this problem, if anyone has a suggestion.