Using a Wester Digital Essential 320GB External Hardisk on both Tiger and..

Hi I've just bought a Using a Wester Digital Essential 320GB External Hardisk with the hope of using it on both my New Macbook Pro with Tiger and my old G4 with Panther.

Which format should I choose ro re format it to use on both.

If it's not compatible with Panther and the G4, what's the best format for using it just with the Intel Macbook Pro and Tiger? I'll be transferring to a new Macbook Pro with Leopard, hence why I bought the harddisk.

Thanks

MBP 17" C2D, Mac OS X (10.4)

Posted on Apr 4, 2008 11:48 AM

Reply
3 replies

Apr 4, 2008 12:28 PM in response to Scottishengineer

Best to initially format it on the G4. The MacBook Pro formatting may not be readable by panther. Note this migration tip:

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=435350&tstart=0

Also note any operating system installed on the G4 won't be bootable by the MacBook Pro or vice versa. A dual formatting option was discussed on this tip:

http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=2006061610374449

Apr 5, 2008 5:55 AM in response to a brody

Hi thanks for you answer,

But I think it looks a bit complicated for the mean time. On my old G4 with a full 60 gig hard disk the only things I want to back up are photos, music and files such as .docs, small photoshop and Illustrator files not whole user accounts or applications because I have all the new applications on the Macbook Pro ready to go on the new one and back ups on CDs.

So what I think I'll do is put backing the the G4 up on hold.

My main task I've just prioritized is how to transfer my Tiger Macbook Pro to a new Leapoard Macbook Pro, since it will be a replacement due to to errors with the screen, I won't have the two computers present at the same time. Hence why I've bought my first external hard disk.

Most importantly I need to store all the precious work I've been doing on my Macbook Pro for the last year and transfer it on to the new one.

At the same time I'd like to have both Windows and Leapoard on the new Macbook Pro instead of just the Mac OS like I have just now.

So I've just bought this new Western Digital MyBook Essential 320g and was wondering what would be the best way to format it so I can transfer not only the files that are on my present Macbook Pro but also all the applications (or some of the applications, the main priority would be the files though but applications would be a bonus)

I've heard that FAT32 is good for transferring between PCs and Macs but it can be unreliable if it accidently disconnects you can loose all the files and although it can work well for small files it doesn't work for applications (Adobe Creative Suite, Microsoft Office etc). Should I just use Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and transfer over files and the applications in their compressed .dmg file format?

The other thing that worries me is that in order to have windows and mac, after I've got Windows OME or whatever it's called, when you go to install through boot camp it partitions your disc automatically, when it does this partition will one of them be OS Extended (Journaled) ?

So will it be just a case of click and drag afterwards and will all my files (simular to the ones on G4 in style, photos, music, small graphic files, .docs etc) be intact?

After I've successfully backed up all my old Tiger Macbook Pro files on the new macbook Pro with Leopard, I will then go and back up the small important files in the G4 (not whole hard disk or user account) to the external hard disk. I may reformat it again afterwards with the tips you give?

So is the best way to do it is write zeros over your external hard disk whilst formating it to OS Extended (Journaled) (for the meantime) through the Macbook Pro? (it would take years with the old G4)

Any other tips? Now that I think about it a partition may be not necessary at this stage after all right?

To be honest external hard disks like WD confuse me to no end and if they had a decent UK tech support line I'd just call it because the only set up instructions are four little initial set up pictures like an IKEA furniture manual.

Cheers and sorry if this has been answered elsewhere.

Apr 7, 2008 6:28 AM in response to Scottishengineer

My main task I've just prioritized is how to transfer my Tiger Macbook Pro to a new Leapoard Macbook Pro, since it will be a replacement due to to errors with the screen, I won't have the two computers present at the same time. Hence why I've bought my first external hard disk.


If a Mac shipped with Leopard, it can't run Tiger. So you are going to have to skip that task if that is the case.

The other thing that worries me is that in order to have windows and mac, after I've got Windows OME or whatever it's called, when you go to install through boot camp it partitions your disc automatically, when it does this partition will one of them be OS Extended (Journaled) ?


As for installnig Windows on the Mac, I'd ask questions in the Boot Camp forum:
http://discussions.apple.com/category.jspa?categoryID=237

Or look at one of the alternatives listed on my FAQ*:

http://www.macmaps.com/macosxnative.html#WINTEL

So will it be just a case of click and drag afterwards and will all my files (simular to the ones on G4 in style, photos, music, small graphic files, .docs etc) be intact


Depends on the program. iPhoto for instance wants photos inside a Pictures folder to include all the xml files inside that folder. So you want to have a wholesale copy of the entire Pictures folder for iPhoto. Other programs are not so sensitive.

My recommendation is not to backup any system files from one computer to another. You can backup your user documents, but I'd also keep a copy on the external hard drive. Anything you want to be opened by Mac applications, keep on an HFS+ Journalled formatted drive or partition.

- * Links to my pages may give me compensation.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Using a Wester Digital Essential 320GB External Hardisk on both Tiger and..

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.