which mac mini for the same price?

Question

which mac mini for the same price?

Hello. I am about to purchase a new mac mini. Either the 1.24 ghz w/combo drive or the 1.42 ghz w/combo drive..

here are the specs for the 1.25ghz model i would get:
1GB DDR333 SDRAM - 1 DIMM
80GB Ultra ATA drive
Combo Drive
Internal Bluetooth
56K v.92 Modem
Mac OS X - U.S. English
1.25GHz PowerPC G4
ATI Radeon 9200 w/32MB DDR video memory

Here are the 1.42ghz specs that I would get:
1GB DDR333 SDRAM - 1 DIMM
80GB Ultra ATA drive
Combo Drive
Internal Bluetooth + AirPort Extreme Card
No modem
Mac OS X - U.S. English
1.42GHz PowerPC G4
ATI Radeon 9200 w/32MB DDR video memory

Both models with the specs above will cost the same at the apple store at 774.00

I have heard the 1.25ghz model's hard drive is a bit faster at 5400rpm. Is this a good reason to go with the 1.25ghz model? The only other difference in specifications between these two models is that the 1.42ghz model also includes the airport extreme card(I dont plan on getting the base station, but it could always be a possibilty in the future).

The way I want these models configured costs exactly the same...the only differences being are the cpu speed, hard drive speed, and the airport extreme card.

I have owned a G4 dual 1ghz powermac, and a g3 800mhz ibook. Needless to say, I love apple and the OSX opperating system!

I am also considering the emac, but I am on a budget here. I will only be using this for the basic stuff(no cpu-intensive programs running here).

I also dont want the superdrive becasue if I ever need one, I will buy an external firewire burner.

Any and all advise will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance for any help you can offer in my decision!

-jason

Posted on Sep 22, 2005 12:48 PM

Reply

Answer 1

Wade Peeler

Level 6

10,906 points

Sep 23, 2005 4:55 PM in response to jason truswell

That's what we call a rumor. 😉

From the above specs, I would get the 1.42GHz with the AP Extreme. Having wireless built-in is nice, and who needs a modem anymore? Plus the CPU is a bit faster, and do we know for sure the respective hard drive speeds?

[ Edited by Apple Discussions Moderator; rumor removed ]

Reply

Answer 2

Sep 23, 2005 5:02 PM in response to Wade Peeler

Wade,

I should have added some ironical remark with my previous post 🙂

I concur with your advice. The built-in BT&AE is nice and would cost a bit more when added at some moment to the 1.25 mini after purchase. Drive speeds remain a surprise until plugging the mini in when it has arrived. No specs are stated at the Apple Store.

I too would say: go for the 1.42 with the BT&AE. I know I did, but I had to pay for the extras...

JJ

Reply

Answer 3

rfruth

Level 3

550 points

Sep 23, 2005 5:20 PM in response to jason truswell

I heard about the processor speed bump & faster hard disk but nothing about additional video RAM, needless to say i'm drooling ... anyway I find a modem near essential even though I have/use/like ADSL sometimes it craps out but good ole dial-up still works.

Reply

Answer 4

AndyO

Level 6

17,064 points

Sep 23, 2005 5:31 PM in response to jason truswell

Whether Apple are, or are not, about to release bumped minis is not something anyone who has genuine knowledge is permitted to discuss or confirm. That there are rumors is true, but there have been rumors of all sorts of Apple products before - so proved true, but an amazing number proved otherwise.

Given the intended use the original poster described, it seems highly likely to me that ANY mini would be more than adequate. The more RAM the better, the faster the better, but where budget is tight and where there are no extraordinary user expecations or demands, a 1.25 mini with 512Mb RAM is a very capable system.

If Airport and or Bluetooth is required, the cost of adding them to the 1.25 model is sufficiently high that the 1.412 would make more sense. If a modem is needed and yet Airport or BT is desired, the 1.42 with built to order modem would be best. If using a RAM-hungry application such as Photoshop, the 1.25 qwith 1GHz RAM will run more smoothly and faster than a 1.42 with 512Mb RAM. Where processor hungry applications are involved (video editing for example) a 1.42 with 512Mb would generally perform a tad faster than a 1.25 with 1Gb - except when it comes to rendering effects and transitions etc.

If budget allows, the 1.42 model with 1Gb RAM and a modem added would be pretty much ideal for power vs cost. And if still considering after a week, who knows, there may be bumped up models - though the same general principles by which to weigh the options would still apply.

Reply

Answer 5

MacRicky

Level 3

744 points

Sep 23, 2005 5:55 PM in response to jason truswell

Jason

I would still get the modem as the built in fax in OS 10.x.x works/requires(?) it. The aircard could then be used for a broadband connection to wireless or ethernet dsl or cable modem.

I concur that the more RAM the better but to add it later is easier the to add aircard modem or if you need it bluetooth.

As you consider your options you can always which the apple store tab for what the lastest offering from Apple might be.

Rick

Reply

Answer 6

aspalten

Level 2

315 points

Sep 25, 2005 4:00 PM in response to jason truswell

I'd seriously consider the eMac option. At 774 bucks, you are only 20 bucks and an additional memory stick away from a superior product.

Andrew

Reply

Answer 7

Sep 27, 2005 4:29 PM in response to jason truswell

Someone earlier asked what evidence on apples website supports the earlier, and mod removed, statement that new minis are coming out right around the corner ie..days.

Apple has updated it's docs to reflect new minis.

http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=25517

For the lazy: (Look at the last line "Sept 2005")

Mac mini

Mac mini * Jan 2005 10.3.7 10.4 7T21, 8A428
Mac mini (late 2005) * Sept 2005 10.4.2 - 8D40

Reply