iDVD burns disc, but blurry motion

Hi,
I have an 80-minute final cut pro movie that has chapter markers. I exported it as a self-contained quicktime movie (125GB) and imported it into iDVD. Since it was so large I burned it on a DVD+R Dual Layer and encoded it as "Best Performance".
Everything looked great in preview mode, but the final burned DVD has really bad digitizing/blurring whenever there is any motion on screen or camera movement.
I really could use any help!!!
Thank you in advance!
-Laura

G5 Mac Pro, Mac OS X (10.4.11)

Posted on May 16, 2008 8:34 AM

Reply
18 replies

May 16, 2008 8:59 PM in response to Laura Seivert

Laura:

Welcome to the Apple Discussions. What is the playing time of the movie? If it is less than 120 minutes including menus you can burn it to a single layer DVD-R disk.

What speed did you burn it at? It's best to burn at the slowest speed possible to get the highest quality burn. Also try using the Professional Quality setting. Are you saving as a disk image before burning to disk? If not it's a good way of checking out the encoding before burning. You can mount the disk image and play it with DVD Player. If it plays satisfactorily that way then it should play that way if it's a good burn and good media. Verbatim DVD-R disks is the brand most recommended.



OT

May 16, 2008 9:41 PM in response to Laura Seivert

You have some top notch advice from OT here.... Suggest you follow it to the letter.


Also, if by chance you still have no joy with the completed /burned DVD, then try using Roxio Toast instead of iDvd to burn it to the media mentioned above by OT (which I will also second). Verbatim is best but Maxell would be my second choice.


Btw, Have you tried burning as a QT reference movie as opposed to a self-contained movie to reduce the size of the above 80 min. / 125 GB !!! file?



Click Here
User uploaded file



User uploaded file




Good luck & good night.


User uploaded file


User uploaded file

May 17, 2008 10:58 AM in response to Laura Seivert

All good advice.

However, I want to know what codec you used to export an 80-minute movie that created a 125GB file? iDVD will be expecting something along the lines of a DV file which is 13GB/hour. The preview function is merely showing you your uncompressed file, so it should look the same. If you follow the advice above (making a disc image) that will show you the actual compressed file.

Mike

May 19, 2008 10:07 AM in response to Old Toad

Hi OT,
Thank you so much for your response and suggestions. I saved the file as a disc image and sure enough the movement in that was messed up as well. I am still not quite sure why it is doing that. My video in final cut is uncompressed, not DV, so I am wondering if that is why I'm having the problem. I've been trying to read other posts but have not found a solution yet. I am using Verbatim discs so I've ruled that out. I'm thinking it is probably something with iDVD but I've never had this problem before.

Thanks again for your help!
Laura

May 20, 2008 3:02 PM in response to Mike Bisom1

Mike,
Thank you so much for asking me that question. That was exactly the problem. Everything I do is always uncompressed video, which of course is why it was so big... when I exported it with chapter markers as "quicktime movie" I kept my current settings (which my manuel said to do) - as soon as I changed it to DV-NTSC it dropped to 16GB. Thanks to everyone who offered some advice!

May 21, 2008 6:46 AM in response to Laura Seivert

Laura


Very glad to see you and Mike goth this worked out. I wish I could of offered more help but I always start out shooting in DV-NTSC hence I don't encounter this issue often. That and I always launch i-apps (or pro apps) when my camcorder (TRV900) is actually plugged in to the computer and most of the time the app will default to the correct settings.

@Mike ...... well done.

User uploaded file


User uploaded file

May 21, 2008 5:48 PM in response to Laura Seivert

I have run into a similar problem. I have been trying to burn a DVD with several quicktime videos (a little less than 5 GBs total) through iDVD, but I get the motion blur problem with the end product. I changed the encoding to best quality which has reduced the motion blur (at least in the disk image... I haven't done a burn of it yet), but I was wondering if anyone had any suggestions to fix the problem completely. It's a large project. The runtime is a little over two hours, so it's on a double layer DVD.

May 21, 2008 7:24 PM in response to Micah986

There is no sure fire way to get rid of motion blur completely when shooting under 30 frames per second / 29.97. But you can reduce its effects by following seven simple rules:





1. Use high quality encoding (depending on run time). This doesn't mean setting it at best quality but rather at Best Performance or Pro settings when appropriate and called for.


2. Keep video playback under 60 mins. whenever possible. ( And remember that slideshows, added audio, motion menus, etc. use up space on the media itself and hence reduce available playback at its highest quality).


3. Use video footage with little or no camera movement in terms of panning or fast moving objects.


4. Make a disc image to the desktop and test the image with apple's dvd player app prior to burning the movie to DVD-R.


5. Lower the burn speed to 4x or lower.



6. When you exceed 60 mins. of QT playback (and up to 120 mins max) use Dual Layer media instead of single layer.



7. Use Verbatim or Maxell DVD-R.


User uploaded file

May 21, 2008 8:00 PM in response to SDMacuser

I've been trying to figure out how to lower the burn speed but haven't been able to find where to do that. Is that under iDVD somewhere?

Also, I have iDVD 6 and the pro setting for encoding isn't an option. It seems that best quality will probably work best for this project as it is longer. I saved the disc image and it looked better than when I had it on best performance. Do you know if Toast is a better program to burn with?

Also, I have several smaller videos. The longest is thirty minutes and I think the average is about fifteen. Does the video playback rule (number 2 on your list) pertain to the total video playback or each video? I'm using a dual layer dvd so I thought that help with the encoding/motion blur problem. Would you suggest taking off some of the videos and burning it to a separate dvd?

Thanks.

May 21, 2008 8:43 PM in response to Micah986

You may want to post your question to the iDvd6 Forum as well since iDvd'08 is significantly different from all earlier versions of this app. That and we really make every effort on these Forums to keep troubleshooting categorized by application and version number so folks don't get confused.


Keep in mind that in earlier versions of iDvd6 you will need to lower the burn speed thru either Roxio Toast (which is what I prefer) or apple's disc utility (the option to lower the speed becomes available after hitting the burn button).


Also iDvd 6 only allows for 2 encoding options (not 3) namely Best Quality and Best Performance. Only iDvd'08 offers the 3rd option or Pro settings as well.


Hope this helps and please remember in the future to post in the appropriate forum for the most accurate responses to your question/s.


Good luck.


User uploaded file

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iDVD burns disc, but blurry motion

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.