33982 Views 13 Replies Latest reply: Nov 10, 2008 1:27 PM by tyoh
I'm currently trying to replace a cracked 17" screen in an Intel Core 2 Duo iMac with a working one from a 17" G5 iMac. The intel screen is an LG Philips part number LM171W02 (TL) (B2) and the G5 screen is an LG Philips part number LM171W02 (A4) (K2). The screens look identical but so far, when I hook up the LM171W02 (A4) (K2) from the iMac G5 to the Intel iMac the intel iMac will not boot. If I re-attach the old screen (LM171W02 TL B2) everything works fine, except for the nasty crack across the lcd of course! I've tried switching lvds cables and so far, no go. If I get it working I'll post my results.
Please keep us up to date. I have the ol' vertical stripe problem and was thinking of salvaging a junked 17" G5 iMac for a replacement screen. It will be frustrating if it turns out that my iMac requires a specific model(s) of screen.
Here is a spec sheet for one of LG Philips's screens (not sure if this helps at all):
I'm not sure what model of screen is in my system but I'm still trying to find more info.
O.k. Here's what I've learned so far trying to fix a busted LCD on my 17" iMac Core 2 Duo (1st gen. with the x1600).
LG Philips #
LM171w02-A4 NO BOOT ( from a G4 iMac 800- will work on the G5 iMac though)
LM171w02-A4 K2 NO BOOT (G5 iMac)
LM171w02-TT A1 NO BOOT (G5 iMac w/iSight)
LP171Wp4-TL B4 (from a PC laptop with a glossy screen) the LVDS cable socket is too small! and the mounting screw holes are completely different!
LM171W02-TL B1 WORKS !!
LM171w02- TL B2 WORKS !!
The (A4) panels will not boot. The lamp plugs and the LVDS cable fit but the pinout is different and the LVDS cables have different wiring. Unless someone wants to try re-wiring a LVDS cable then it's not going to work.
Right now I'm scouring eBay for a LM171w02-TL ## screen in decent shape.
The panel listed in a previous post is not LVDS based but TMDS based. They are different. Also it is most likely that the various panels won't work because the EDID information that is stored on each panel is different. It would require reading the EDID information on your existing panel and re-programming the new one.
So will a G5 17inch panel work on a G4 iMac 1Ghz do you think ? I know it seems like a backward step but the G4's screen is cracked and the G5 has a logic board problem!
I've also got a friend looking for a new panel to fit a 17inch iMac Intel - two years old and covered with vertical lines but I don't think Apple will recognise it as a defect.
Hi tyoh, new account? Your first post is very interesting.
That's mean only Apple can fix this problem and we need to pay Apple again to fix it if we don't have the warranty? If Apple can really fix it, how come the "vertical line" problems still appear and appear and appear...
Is that the quality of your replacement not good enough? If I were you, I will ask for exchange a new one immediately and confirm where is the problem, not just counting how many lines are coming up...after few days =]
I'm waiting for another replacement panel from the reseller.
I bet it will be the same.
One thing that I'd like to check. Does you iMac go sleep properly? I've been aware that mine didn't go sleep properly causing high degree of temperature. I was told by an engineer that vertical lines are caused by higher temperature.