DVD compatibility Europe-Argentina

My wife's a teacher in Belgium and this year, her school did a twinning project with a school in La Plata, Argentina.
A month ago, the school organised a festival with different acivities, performances, etc.
I filmed the whole event with a Sony camcorder and then edited everything in iMovie 06. I then moved everything tot iDVD 08 and added some menu's and some other cool stuff.
Now, as we live in Belgium, Europe, the DVD region is 2, whereas it's 1 in the US. There's also the differene in television standard, NTSC in the US and Japan, PAL in Europe.
Now I have already discovered that a DVD made and burned with iDVD is region "free", meaning ALL regions. Argentina is region 4, but that shouldn't pose a problem anyway. I also discovered that Argentina uses the PAL standard, but it's PAL-N, whereas we use PAL-B/G. Now, before DVD, there was another standard, SECAM, which was mainly used in France. When you bought a VHS in France, you couldn't play it in a PAL VCR (well, you could, but it was black and white). When DVD's came to pass, France did away with Secam and they used the PAL-standard as well. I don't know if NTSC has different types standards as well, but to cut a long story short, is PAL-N compatible with PAL B/G ?
In other words, will the DVD's I give the people to take back to Argentina work in their DVD-players ? Most DVD-players sold in Belgium support both the PAL and NTSC standard (as do the television sets), but I don't know about Argentina.

iMac G5 20"/2.1Ghz 2.5Gb - iBook G4 14"/1.42Ghz 1.5Gb - iPod Video 5.5G white, Mac OS X (10.4.11), LaCie external HD Porsche Design 500Gb Firewire/USB2

Posted on Jun 27, 2008 2:17 AM

Reply
5 replies

Jun 27, 2008 3:09 AM in response to Rincewind

Rincewind wrote:
.. , but I don't know about Argentina.


me either 😀

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAL
.. says, Argentina has its very own 'standard' of PAL ..

.. if time allows it, I would create a PAL = maybe you're lucky..
and, 2nd one: set iDVD to 29.97 fps (=NTSC) and create a NTSC-version of your project.. as you allready know, PAL-DVDplayers support NTSC disks.. so, maybe the PAL-N machines in Argentina do accept a NTSC-disk? ..

Jun 27, 2008 4:22 AM in response to Karsten Schlüter

Well, it's a bit too late to burn the DVD in NTSC. I've made everything in PAL and already made 60 copies to give to the children's parents here in Belgium. I only need 5 copies for Argentina but there's no time to redo the whole project. I guess I'll just keep my fingers crossed. But as far as I can tell from the Wikipedia article, everything should be just fine !

Message was edited by: Rincewind

Jun 27, 2008 5:49 AM in response to Rincewind

Hi Rincewind

I'm Argentina. The local TV standard is PAL-N, but for video DVD there are no PAL flavor problems.

But ... between other issues that make our country unique and special 🙂 we have a very "funny" video DVD policy here. As I told you boradcast TV is PAL. In the VHS era all rental movies were PAL. Till that great, right?

Whwn DVD players and rented movies arrived here, everything changed in the play. Most probably because some market reasons, the DVD business "aligned" with the USA market, meaning that all the movies in what we call "video clubs" (Blockbusters and so) are NTSC region 4 (weird!!!!!) and all the dvd players sold in the first years of the DVD fever were just NTSC compatibles. That was not noted for the standard movie viewer because all TV sets here are PAL and NTSC, then they never found that issue.

If you want big names, most of the SONY DVD players not even play the PAL discs, giving an "zone error" message, what is worst!! They show that message even the DVDs were zone free (I make all DVD in DVDSP as multizone). The newets models are PAL compatible.

Other brands like Panasonic, Philips, etc delivered players that played PAL DVDs in black and white.

A complete mess that makes me change standards from PAL (I shoot in PAL with a Pana DVX-100) to NTSC for DVD projects for home users. The only way to be sure they will be able to play fine.

The best part of the story is that the ceapest DVD players from China and so are PAL compatibles.

How do you concvince your customer that SONY sold them incompatyible players with the local TV standard? They trust the brand name and think you are trying to make them fool.

Nice, ahhh!?!?!?!

Then your PAL copies probably will play fine in color depending on the brand of the players.

If you need local assistance in this matter feel free to contact me : silal (at) mac (dot) com

Good luck ... buena suerte !! 😉

Hope that helps !

User uploaded file
Alberto

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

DVD compatibility Europe-Argentina

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.