look fellas...the AFP service and spotlight service is buggy at best....
doesnt matter what hardware you run or which 10.5.x software...
it doesnt work right period....all the points you guys made are valid.
here is the solution:
get a windows server box 2000 or 2003 or even an XP box
and run this
http://www.grouplogic.com/products/extremeZ-IP/
super fast searches...indexing...i mean fast....works with all apple clients.
take the time to try it free...easy to setup up....works period...
no missing file nonsense...thats pretty much all they do and have excellent support.
i have started to abandon my xserves...and move this way...
hopefully with "snow leopard" they will finally address real issues...
and stop adding useless features....maybe get enterprise level
support where it should be...these servers are too expensive to have these stupid issues.
hopefully less engineering hours at iphone would make a difference.
good luck
Luis.
see my other posts in the 10.4.x forums.
personal info - i have 4 xserves runing 10.5.5, 10.4.11, 10.4.11, 10.3.9
and i support over 70 clients...so iam not talking out of my butt.