Powerbook G3 is _VERY_ slow

I've recently acquired a Powerbook G3 PDQ for free and am trying to fix it up.

The problem is, that it's running VERY slowly. The OS takes maybe 20 minutes to boot (but it gets there). Nothing responded (or seemed to before I lost patience) when I tried to click on a menu item.

It seems that the G3 has had it's hardware fiddled with, though I can't be sure. The keyboard isn't locked in place, and easily comes out. I can only assume someone else either tried to, or actually upgraded/changed some components.

I'm assuming I have a hardware problem, and since I'm currently in India, I doubt I'll be able to acquire the proper replacement parts. But I'm still hoping that there's something I can do for the laptop.

BTW, I've already reset the PRAM.

Any advice would be helpfull.


- Gora

PowerBook G3 PDQ, Mac OS 9.1.x, 14.1TFT/300MHz-1MB/64MB/8GB HD/4MB video/DVD/Modem

Posted on Aug 21, 2008 5:49 PM

Reply
10 replies

Aug 21, 2008 7:42 PM in response to lloth

Gora,

Welcome to the Discussions.

Since you know you have a Powerbook G3 PDQ, I just want to make sure is the one with no USB or FireWire. If you have this model, it is commonly known as the Wallstreet.
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=24604

I would think the HD is causing the very slow startup, either a failing a HD or possibly one that can be salvaged through specific procedures. However, you are going need a bootable CD to work on the HD plus a System CD to reinstall the OS.

Booting normally to a CD will again point to the HD as the problem. Not knowing which OS is installed, try restarting while pressing/holding the shift key. This will allow only the minimum files required to boot the powerbook to load in both OS9 and OSX...see if it starts any faster. In OS9, you can release the key when you see 'extensions off' in the window with the MacOS 9 logo; it will take longer to reach the message 'Safe Boot' in OSX.

The Wallstreet has these system requirements: A retail MacOS 8.5 > 9.2.2 and MacOS X up to 10.2.8.

Aug 22, 2008 12:41 AM in response to lloth

Additional information:

* A 256M Module has been put inside the Powerbook.
* Holding shift put it into "safe mode" boot, but that doesn't affect anything.
* command-option-p-r - works.
* command-option-o-f - produces no results.
* Trying to boot off an original Mac OS 8.5 CD has no effect (the CD is ignored). I boot while holding the 'c' button.
* I get a "Your computer did not shut down properly. Disk First Aid is checking your hard drive and will repair any problems". That runs nice and speedily. (including when I click the "ok" button")

- Gora

Aug 22, 2008 6:07 AM in response to lloth

lloth welcome to Apple Discussions.

Here's some helpful laptop sites. They may help you secure the keyboard & other repairs.

Fix It Guides for Mac Laptops & Mini
http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/
The guides can be viewed on-line or you can download a PDF file.

How to Upgrade, Repair, Disassemble an Apple/Macintosh Laptop or Notebook
http://repair4laptop.org/disassembly_apple.html

PowerBookTech
http://www.powerbooktech.com/
(Note - PowerBookTech has some good info, however, some Mac users in other forums were having difficulty getting delivery on parts from them.)

How to Upgrade, Repair, Disassemble an Apple/Macintosh Laptop or Notebook
http://repair4laptop.org/disassembly_apple.html

Laptop Repair Guides
http://www.applerepairmanuals.com/#portables

MicroDock
http://www.microdocusa.com/

When you get it booted up, click once on the desktop & then select About This Computer under the Apple Menu. How much RAM is installed and is Virtual Memory On or Off?

 Cheers, Tom 😉

User uploaded file

Aug 22, 2008 6:41 AM in response to lloth

Gora:
Your computer did not shut down properly. Disk First Aid is checking your hard drive and will repair any problems

If you got this message while booted from the CD, it shows that computer itself it fine. However, like jpl, I suspect your Hard Disk Drive. Disk First Aid checks and repairs the directory, that is the filesystem or electronic structure which enables your computer to store and retrieve information. The HDD hardware may still be failing, even if the check seems ok. Unfortunately the WallStreet does not support Apple Hardware Test.

😉 cornelius

Aug 22, 2008 7:01 AM in response to lloth

Ok next update:

Once I let it sit for a LONG time (1 - 1.5 hours). It fully boots Mac OS 9.1, and runs perfectly fine.

Some things, like edit->preferences runs slowly, but opening up a jpeg, or even a word document are fast. The partition manager (??) for Norton bogs the system down, but opening Norton scan disk ran fine. (I didn't run it, I just opened the application.)

Seems to me that some aspect of system memory is broken, and when it wants to read/write to it, it lags. Maybe that's why I can't boot into the Open Firmware prompt? (Ctr-Opt-O-F fails to do anything.)

Also, I've tried to boot two CDs, but both have failed. A Debian distro for PPC and an original Mac OS 8.5 CD. However when I was in the OS, I could browse the Mac OS 8.5 disk, so the CD and my drive are working fine.

Any ideas for tests? Or better yet, fixes?

- Gora


PS: I get a happy Mac while booting, before the main OS starts loading.

RAM: 128M + a 256M chip = 384. I believe that Virtual Memory is on, I'll check it again after another hour (I just rebooted the system) when it's done booting.

Message was edited by: lloth

Message was edited by: lloth

Aug 22, 2008 7:12 AM in response to lloth

Gora,

A failure to boot to a CD could have several causes. Do you hear the optical drive try to spin up?

-a non-compatible CD. Are you sure the OS 8.5 CD is a retail release and not a machine-specific CD that may have a computer's name on it? The latter will not boot the powerbook. Here is what one looks like:
http://www.amazon.com/OS-8-5-Full-Install-Universal/dp/B0010KEFSW

-corrupted PRAM. When resetting the PRAM (command-option-R-P), press the four keys immediately after the startup chime, then wait for 2 additional chimes; if you don't hear the additional chimes, you did not press the keys soon enough. On the Wallstreet, it may take some time between chimes.

-dirty or scratched CD.

-failed optical drive.

After resetting the PRAM again, and if the 'c' key will still not boot the CD, try booting the optical disk while pressing the 'delete-option-command-shift' keys; this forces a bypass of the HD.

Unfortunately, if all of the above fails, there is no simple way to boot the Wallstreet to another volume. With legacy ports, you need an external SCSI HD or optical drive (one that has firmware compatible with a Mac) or you need to connect the Wallstreet to another Mac with a SCSI port in a procedure called SCSI Disk Mode.

Aug 22, 2008 7:33 AM in response to lloth

Gora,

If your powerbook still takes 20 minutes or 1.5 hours to boot, yet you get no crashes/freezes, your memory is fine; you have an HD problem. Memory will not cause a slowdown like you are experiencing.

Are you resetting the PRAM from a shut down state (cold start)?
------------------------
Here are the steps for resetting Open Firmware:

Boot into Open Firmware by holding down the 'Command-Option-O-F' keys from a cold start while the chime is being played. You will see a command-line screen...enter these commands:

1. At the Open Firmware prompt, type: reset-nvram
2. Press Return.
3. At the Open Firmware prompt, type: reset-all
4. Press Return.
Example:
0 > reset-nvram
Press Return
0 > reset-all
Press Return

The reset-all command should cause the computer to restart. If this occurs, you have successfully reset the Open Firmware settings.
------------------------

Aug 22, 2008 9:19 AM in response to jpl

jpl,

The machine runs fine when it's not doing something related to the system. Word, viewing jpg, browsing folders, all work fine and fast. When I go to set the time, it slows down again.

Right now I'm running Norton FileSaver (which said: "There is damage to the Volume Header Block.") and Norton DiskDoctor. Diskdotor runs very fast, scanning the HD. But slows down sometimes in the middle of "Checking Media". I'll let it run all night and see what happens. (It's night here)

I'll try your advice tomorrow, but in the past when I've tried to boot to the Open Firmware prompt the Powerbook ignores the "Command-Option-O-F" key sequence and just boots the OS.

Thanks for all the help. 🙂

- Gora

PS: My current guess is that you're right, that it's a failing HD that's not quite dead.

Aug 22, 2008 12:36 PM in response to lloth

Gora,

If one were interested in trying to recover an HD, an erase/install of all software would be the first procedure. But if you were to travel this path, the cover-all-bases approach would be this:

1. Boot to a MacOS 8.x/9.x CD and open Drive Setup located in the Utilities folder on the CD (you cannot have any files in use from the HD).
2. Select your HD in the window, then in the Initialization Options, you check the box for 'zero all data'; this will take time.
3. After zeroing, you run Test Disk; this will also take time.
4. If OK, initialize as MacOS Extended (HFS+) and reinstall software.
5. When Drive Setup is launched, Drive Setup Help in the menu bar covers HD maintenance.

Zeroing accomplishes two things: (1) it thoroughly cleans the HD; (2) it spares (reallocates) any bad blocks. The Test Disk reads/writes to each block; if it fails, zero and test the HD again. If it fails again, the HD is bad.

Of course in order to perform the above, you need a bootable MacOS CD to zero/test/reinstall all software.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Powerbook G3 is _VERY_ slow

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.