New to Mac ~ Mac Mini vs. HP?

Good morning everybody,

I use Windows but I want to change to Mac. I'm thinking about buying the Mac Mini Superdrive. I was comparing the Mac Mini to the HP Pavilion Elite (m9420f), they are both pretty much the same price, but I noticed the memory and hard drive is much larger in the HP.

I use the computer for reglar use ~ photo storing and editing, downloading videos. I don't do any gaming.

Here's the info on each:

*Mac Mini:
160 GB hard drive
2 GB ram
speed 2.0 Ghz Intel core duo

*HP Pavilion m9420f:
640 GB hard drive
7 GB RAM
speed 2.30 Ghz Intel core 2 Quad

I'm not familiar with the numbers when it comes to memory. Would I still be ahead if I buy the Mac? I know that it doesn't need virus protection (and I've been having lots of virus problems lately).

What else can the Mac do to sell me on it? 😀

Thanks for your help!

Mac Mini, Other OS, New to Mac

Posted on Nov 8, 2008 8:27 AM

Reply
6 replies

Nov 10, 2008 7:35 AM in response to Kia2426

Welcome to Apple Discussions!

I'm not sure the right place to start in considering your possible choice of systems is to try and match specifications to see which is 'best'. If price and on-paper performance were the major criteria, you would almost certainly be advised to look for a good Windows-based PC within your budget.

The real choice here is not hardware but operating system. Do you want a Windows systems to run Windows-based applications, or a Mac to run MacOS and MacOS-based software? In other words, ask yourself why you are considering a Mac at this point in time. Is it because Macs are supposedly 'better'? Because there's something specific you want the system to do that a Mac is likely to do better than a Windows PC? Have you used a Mac?

If you have an interest in MacOS because it has better inherent security, is (so far) free from the sort of malware, spyware and adware that tends to make even the most powerful Windows PC slow down to pedestrian speeds, and is capable of running suites of applications smoothly and seamlessly, then a Mac mini is an excellent choice. To be sure, based on laptop components it would not be the fastest system in the universe, but for anything short of professional-level/high demand environments, it is remarkably capable and very satisfying to use.

When comparing the sort of performance you might expect from comparable MacOS and Windows systems, there are many factors other than CPU speed and RAM to consider. As mentioned above, it's necessary to factor in the CPU load used by essential processes such as antivirus scanners and monitors in the Windows environment which are not really an issue in macOS at all. It is also not necessary spend money (or time) dealing with security software in the MacOS environment so there is less maintenance required and awareness of the system needed, and little or no expenditure on defensive software which is an essential addition to a Windows system. That isn't to say that Macs and MacOS are entirely without risks or that they will stay that way, but there is a free, open source, malware solution for Macs (ClamXav) with can be downloaded and deployed and which with a small effort can be configured to run very lightly on the system when it is needed at all.

The result is that for many, a lower-performance system running MacOS can significantly outperform a higher performance system running Windows.

And then there's the software. Most Windows systems come with no software, or with free or trialware versions of commercial applications which neither function smoothly together nor offer particularly impressive functionality unless a full version is purchased. Much software that is added to Windows systems at the outset is of dubious value, and often time limited. On the other hand, every mac comes supplied with an excellent suite of media applications to permit storage and manipulation of photos, music, video and the creation of DVDs, along with a simple to use web authoring tool that can create remarkably rich sites with stunning design values, yet requires little more than a few mouse clicks.

That's really the single-most valuable aspect of MacOS in my view - the integration of hardware, OS and software allows for considerable sophistication, yet unparalleled ease of use.

Add to that, the fact that every new Mac can run Windows if you need it to, but Windows PCs can't run MacOS - thus a Mac has rather better flexibility - and that Macs typically have a performance advantage because MacOS is written to be rather more elegant in managing memory, and applications and files are typically rather smaller than Windows equivalents, and thus are less demanding on systems.

However, which one to buy is not about which is 'faster' but which one is most likely to do the job you want it to do, and give you the best user experience while doing it. If you've used a Mac, particularly recent one, then likely you'll already know the answer to that!

Nov 8, 2008 5:32 PM in response to Kia2426

OS X is the biggest factor when looking at buying a Mac or not. Here are the highlights:

1. No viruses/spyware. Period.
2. Almost every app you ever need is on OS X.
3. iLife - apps for photos, music and more. For you, iPhoto is going to be awesome. ( http://www.apple.com/ilife/iphoto/)
4. Stable - Apple controls it all, and the OS is much more stable/faster than XP/Vista
5. You can run XP/Vista if needed.

Nov 9, 2008 12:19 PM in response to Kia2426

I would go with the MacMini. On the MacMini you can have the best of both worlds, where on the HP you are stuck with XP/Vista. You can install XP/Vista on the MacMini along with Mac OS X though Boot Camp. Which comes with the computer. There are two software packages you can buy that will let you run Windows and Mac OS X at the same time.

As the others have already stated it comes with every thing you are going to need when it comes to editing photos and video.

-Locutus

Nov 10, 2008 6:21 AM in response to Kia2426

The Mac mini is really a laptop without a screen, therefore its specs like all laptops is lower than equivalent desktops. Nethertheless, it should be perfectly adequate for what you describe.

If you do find the internal hard disk becomes a limitation it is very easy to add an external FireWire or USB hard drive. 2GB of RAM should be fine for your planned usage.

The Mac mini is quieter than so called silent or hush PCs.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

New to Mac ~ Mac Mini vs. HP?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.