More ridiculous semantics.
I need prove nothing to you. You are one that instigated these blatherings and the onus is therefore on you to prove me wrong.
But for the sake of the OP of this thread (the one you threadjacked for your own ego-trip) who may be getting confused, I will refer to the following:
From Disk Utility's Help Pages:
(Also confirmed in KBase Article
http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1394?viewlocale=en_US )
If you have trouble opening applications or documents, or if your computer is running slowly, the user permissions for some of your files may be set incorrectly. Permission problems sometimes happen after you update your system or install new software. With Disk Utility, you can repair these problems.
Do not use the computer while installing an update:
Though not required for most updates, you may want to avoid using the computer while installing updates.
From KBase Article HT1452:
When possible, disk permissions should be repaired while started up from a Mac OS X volume (hard disk) that contains updated Mac OS X software, instead of a Mac OS X installation disc. Mac OS X software updates may change permissions on some files to improve security. When this occurs, the version of Disk Utility on the Mac OS X volume is updated to account for the new permissions. Running Disk Utility while started from the Mac OS X volume ensures that the changes made by software updates are preserved.
Lastly:
If repairing permissions is useful in general, why doesn’t Apple recommend it as routine maintenance?
Apple does, quite explicitly:
It’s a good idea to repair disk permissions as a regular maintenance task after upgrading or installing new software.
That’s taken from Mac Help—in both Panther and Tiger—right on your Mac.