Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Trackpad Accidental Safari Resizing and Horizontal Scrolling -- Ugh!!

Obviously some other people are also having trouble with this, so I wanted to start a separate thread just on this issue.

I really can't stand the new trackpad's behavior in Safari. It almost makes me not want to surf the web anymore.

Some of these new trackpad finger commands that affect my surfing are just ludicrous! And you can't turn most of them off! It's insane.

Bottom line: My thumb likes to rest on the trackpad sometimes (it's more ergonomic, rather than hovering your thumb above the pad or shuffling it back and forth) but then if I also move my index finger while the thumb's in place, it often unintentionally resizes all the fonts in Safari.

Now I've at times chosen to resize webpage fonts (using command+plus) as needed but now it's FREQUENTLY unintentionally changing them while I do basic surfing. Sorry, but my thumb does need a place to rest and it's going to be on the trackpad some times. Apple really needs to let people turn this annoying feature off. And soon. People don't resize their webpage fonts THAT often to warrant a trackpad command. And I don't think my thumb will get trained over time. Ergonomically it's simply better for you if it can rest on the trackpad as you need it to click there often.

And then they took away the option to turn off horizontal scrolling! Sorry, but I don't like scrolling down a webpage with two fingers only to find I've lost the left margin and am swimming somewhere to the right in the middle of the page. It's totally cool if other people like that, but we should be able to set our own preferences, particularly for something as personal as finger commands (and wow, the page just jumped 2 font sizes just now when I moved to edit a typo).

Come on Apple, give us back a computer we can 100% love! Give us options. And stop the webpage crazy-thinking. Let us get back to doing our jobs and surfing efficiently and quickly.

I don't need this page or any other in a 7 point then 72 point font . . . ever.

Message was edited by: andintroducing

15" Unibody Macbook 2.4 Ghz, Mac OS X (10.5.5)

Posted on Dec 2, 2008 5:30 PM

Reply
11 replies

Dec 2, 2008 8:13 PM in response to Michael Flynn

Yes, indeed it's operating as designed. I'm just suggesting that there is a flaw in the design if the slightest miscalculation causes wild shifts in webpage fonts and horizontal scrolling.

It's all good for people who want the trackpad that way, but for those of us who want a more traditional function, we should be able to turn off the more excessive of the trackpad choices Apple decided for all users.

I generally don't support those kind of arguments, as usually Apple uses their powers for good, but in this case, they negatively affected the browsing experience for thousands upon thousands of people.

It seems that decisions like that would deserve even more "design," testing and/or allowance of choice on their part.

Dec 3, 2008 1:51 AM in response to notmynormalusername

notmynormalusername wrote:
And you should be able to disable it. I think the apple engineers ran out of time designing the Trackpad pref pane 🙂


You used a smiley but you still might be right. If the engineers were given a deadline it is common to drop features to make sure it ships on time. This happens at many companies. You drop anything that might delay meeting the date, and adding features is not just about coding but about surviving the test suite as well.

Dec 3, 2008 4:20 PM in response to Network 23

Do you think they might have had the same kind of oversight with the volume of the trackpad?

That seems to be an issue for a lot of people as well as it's so much louder than previous machines when clicked.

There's a thread on that here:

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1812795&tstart=0

Hopefully Apple will hear that people are having trouble with that and fix it or others will be able to suggest alternatives that help.

Dec 12, 2008 3:32 AM in response to symonty Gresham

And not only does this happen in Safari. If you use Excel, you both have the horizontal scrolling issue and oddly enough a very rapid and imprecise descent under vertical scrolling. And many times, again it happens accidentally. I can barely get work done anymore in the program without having to spend a lot of time refinding my place due to accidental inputs.

Not sure I'll ever NOT have those accidental inputs with Mac's new insane finger language. Gotta be a way to turn it off, even in older programs like Excel from Office 2004. 2008 is just so unstable and Numbers is just confusing (Insert Column Before, Insert Column After?) Just not sure where the old Mac simplicity has gone to.

Jan 24, 2009 5:45 AM in response to andintroducing

This is a big issue in Safari. You don't use a laptop like you use an iPhone. I'm amazed Apple didn't figure this out during testing! It's about impossible not to constantly run into it.

The problem is not resting one's thumb. If your thumb treats the bottom of the trackpad as a button and you place it there preparing to click, then move the mouse with the other finger on the trackpad, you can cause the text to resize. Happens CONSTANTLY.

Please Apple ... let us turn this off as a feature!

Filippo

Jan 24, 2009 2:07 PM in response to Filippo Morelli

Well Guys, I had the same problem and I can tell you what I did to fix it... I switched to the new Firefox 3.1 Beta 2 that supports finger gestures... Then you can (somewhat) edit the finger gestures by going to the website about:config (it lets you change the settings in firefox)... then filter by gesture and you can erase the values for the gestures you don't want to use... in addition to erasing the pinch ones (I set pinch out to reset text size.. same as Command+0), I also switched the swipe gestures values with the twist gestures as I switch tabs much more frequently then going back and forth and find the twist gesture's sensitivity to be off... Good luck guys!
Link to beta: http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/all-beta.html
Suggested Addons to get: Adblock Plus, Download Statusbar and Firefox PDF Plugin for Mac OS X

Trackpad Accidental Safari Resizing and Horizontal Scrolling -- Ugh!!

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.