error code -36, large files on DVD

I have some commercial DVDs that contain large mov files (between 900MB and 1.5GB each). These are royalty free visual effects and it is 100% legal to copy these files to my hard drive...in fact the company recommends it.

Every time I set it up to copy from the DVD to my internal hard drive (just to clarify that I'm importing the files, not trying to burn to DVD), it will get part way through and give me this error: "The Finder cannot complete the operation because some data in "file_name" could not be read or written. (Error code -36)." Finder then hangs and must be relaunched.

It seems that the disc will start off fine, spinning quite fast, but after a while the spinning slows, then stops altogether. Every time I try it stops at different spots in the copy. I have tried deleting the Finder preferences, restarting the computer, contacting the company to see if there's a copy-protection issue, and copying from the disc to a different hard drive (I have 4 internal drives). I have tried the discs on a MacBook and was able to copy one of the discs, but had the same error code with a different disc.

I have copied from discs that have smaller files and those seem to be fine. Even if I try just copying one file at a time rather than the whole disc, I still get the same error. There are 26 DVDs, so copying one file at a time would take forever anyways. I've tried a lot of them, with the same results.

I know this is an I/O error, but why is it only happening on discs with large files? I'm trying not to have to drive all the way to the Apple Store to have them look at it, is there any way to run a hardware test on the optical drive itself and see if it's having issues? Does Finder just not like the file sizes? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Mac Pro Dual 2.66 Duo, 11GB RAM

Posted on Jan 13, 2009 4:17 PM

Reply
4 replies

Jan 14, 2009 1:02 PM in response to direwolf8

Creating the disc image failed with an input/output error. I found a disc that I had burned that has large files similar to these discs and the files imported to my hard drive without a problem. The optical drive appears to be fine so I'm going to try dealing with the company that created these particular DVDs to see if they have any suggestions.

Any other suggestions or recommendations before I ship back this entire library?

Jan 20, 2009 1:02 PM in response to rcsjackson

I have now received a replacement set of discs from the company. Now I'm finding 1/2 of the discs import fine, the other half give me the error code again. What I'm noticing is when I insert the disc and go to view the files, everything seems fine until it tries to create the thumbnails. If it is unable to create all of the thumbnails quickly, then I know it will give me the error code when I try to import. But, if I eject the disc and reinsert it, sometimes it will change which ones show thumbs and which don't. The error code will appear with different file names in the error each time. File size doesn't appear to be an issue as some discs that have been successful have files as large as 1.3GB and as small as 400MB. The discs that fail don't have any larger or smaller files than those for the most part.
Again these are commercially produced discs, i.e. made off a glass master, not just burned on a home duplicator.
I have tried using an external optical drive and have had the same results.
Any other suggestions or other information I can provide to get more suggestions??

Jan 20, 2009 2:43 PM in response to rcsjackson

I have now updated my OS to 10.5.6, problem persists. When Finder creates the thumbnails, usually the first file and last couple files appear fine, then it stops. The optical drive sounds like it hits a wall after creating the successful thumbs. I am able to import some of the individual files off the failing discs, but not all of the ones that get successful thumbs.

These are all .mov files.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

error code -36, large files on DVD

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.