After upgrading my Mac mini Core Solo with a Western Digital 250GB (WD2500BEVS), I see that it is functioning at a temperature of about 122.0F (50°C) degrees inside the Mac mini. Sometimes 53°C even, but never below 48°C. This disk did rarely touch 40°C in a MacBook Core Duo 2.0, it used to be about 36-38°C. Why is it running so much hotter inside the mini? Is it because of that "sponge" sticking on the harddisk as you can see on that link below? I have put that sponge onto the new disk as well. What's it for anyway? Is it safe to try without?
The original 60GB drive of the Mac mini was about the same temperature. Always around 50°C. I just wonder why that newer HD runs so much cooler in a MacBook.
{quote:title=MatthiasSt wrote:} Is it because of that "sponge"{quote}
LOL 🙂 It's called
foam. I can't believe you've never seen a piece of foam before in your life. It's supposed to be there.
Because you got a wrong HDD, Western Digital is the hottest HDD in the world. Maxtor is better, because I have many experience on purchasing HDD, my No.1~3 selection would be : 1.Maxtor 2.Toshiba 3.Hitachi I never thought it would have been WD.
Maxtor is very cold, hottest up to 36 degree C(96F) at most. It never exceed 36C(96F), in most of time, it's on 34C(93F).
But since It's hard to find a Maxtor 2.5" HDD, then the Toshiba or Hitachi became my favorite. and sure, the temperature I measured of these two Japanese HDD are all below 36C.
That's why I never buy WD HDD, because their technology is a little left behind Maxtor(Seagate acquired years ago), Toshiba, Hitachi.
Basically, I think Toshiba and Hitachi are the same level in HDD technology, they know how to make a cold HDD.
34° C were never a problem when that hard drive was inside a MacBook. I saw temperaturs even below that. Like I said before, it barely ever touched 40, and thats after heavy usage.
Same harddisk is now way hotter inside the Mac mini.
The technical manual refers to it as a "sponge", so I used this term. Sounded strange to me too. The instructions don't say anything about keeping it after hard disk replacement.
This thread has been closed by the system or the community team.
You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.
Upgrading the Hard Drive: What's that sponge for?
Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.