No audio when recording from DV camera source using QuickTime pro

I am having a problem when trying to use quicktime pro to record/transcode from DV tapes, using the camera playback as the source. The problem is that the audio from the tape is not showing up in the recorded quicktime movie. Sometimes the audio is present, but it is rare and not repeatable. When I look at the movie properties, it shows an audio track, but no sound comes out when being played back.

My procedure is generally File-->New Recording. Then start the camera playing and as soon as the video starts playing press the record button. Sometimes I try changing the order, press record first then start the camera playing but it doesn't seem to make a difference. The recording format is "Better".

If I use iMovie to import from the camera it works great - the audio always comes through.

The reason for using Quicktime pro is to try to save a transcoding step. This is being used on a set of computers in a university lab and the students have recordings they need to take off the DV tapes and make into a quicktime movie. In the past the iMovie-->export to QuickTime procedure was used but it takes much longer to do that.

The machines are G4 iBooks, 1.33 GHz with 512 RAM. OS X 10.4.11.

This procedure has worked relatively well in the past, for at least a couple of semesters, but now it seems to no longer work as expected. It is possible that the IT dept reimaged these machines and that the version of QT has been updated. I am not in control of the machines. If this had always been the behavior since the beginning then I would suspect that these machines are just not powerful enough to be used in this way, but the fact that they worked in the past makes me wonder what has gone wrong.

I appreciate any ideas or suggestions.

iMac 2.4G Intel, Mac OS X (10.5.6)

Posted on Mar 1, 2009 4:40 PM

Reply
3 replies

Mar 2, 2009 5:05 AM in response to j053ph

The QuickTime Pro "One Click Recording" can't "import" previously recorded files. It can only record "live" input via a Firewire connected camera.
Your lab of G4's are a bit too underpowered, and probably have small hard drives, to use the One Click Recording feature in a "device native" capture (DV Stream @ 13 GB's per hour). The smaller sized files will not have the video quality you're probably after.
Any version of iMovie (1 though 8) can import your recorded files in "real time" and the resulting .dv file could be edited and exported using it or QuickTime Pro.

Mar 2, 2009 7:43 AM in response to j053ph

If you have a lot of this you may want to try two Elgato products - the EYE TV which accepts composite video (and stereo audio) in from the AV out on a DV camera and records in MPEG-2. The video is pretty good quality and the little box has a hardware MPEG-2 encoder chip so it uses little CPU cycles.

It will export to various i-formats like for iPod, iPod touch and in conjunction with the Turbo.264 also from Elgato extremely quickly. The Turbo.264 has a hardware H.264 encoder chip again offloading the tasks from the CPU.

Of course the MPEG-2 imported may be all you need to view and no need to transcode to Quicktime at all.

With G4 ibooks it might save a lot of time as they are not powerhouses by any means.

Mar 3, 2009 8:44 PM in response to QuickTimeKirk

Thank you for your reply. Yes I agree that the machines are underpowered, and yes the video quality is not great. The encoded video is at a much lower frame rate than the source. However, even given the low quality, we were able to encode movies this way before so it seems like something must have changed. I think we need to come up with a different solution now. Thanks again.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

No audio when recording from DV camera source using QuickTime pro

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.