Want to highlight a helpful answer? Upvote!

Did someone help you, or did an answer or User Tip resolve your issue? Upvote by selecting the upvote arrow. Your feedback helps others! Learn more about when to upvote >

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Getting iMovie file to fit on DVD

I have a 1 hr 12 minute iMovie file with video clips, audio, some titles and stills that is 14.47 G total. When I use "create a DVD" I get the "duration is too long"message. I have made sure (following Karl Petersen's advice) to have ONLY the video clips I want in the iMovie file. I exported all clips to Full Quality Quicktime, deleted all clips in the iMovie file, re-imported the .dv files to get my final movie file. I also set the iDVD prefs to Best Quality, not Best performance.

From searching this forum, I read that a movie that is 1 hr 55 minutes should fit on a 4.7 G DVD. The capacity status pane in iDVD shows 4.8 G.

My question (which is obvious already, I'm sure) is what is happening? The file is only 1 hr 12 min long, including everything. My original file after converting from analog to digital was 14.96 G, so it went down a little, to 14.47 G. Seems crazy to split this into 2 DVDs.

When a video is converted from analog to digital, what settings should it have in regards to bit rate, etc? I'm new to this (like lots of people 🙂 I use an old Formac unit to convert the video VHS tape to digital using NTSC, about 30 frames per second, high performance (but not best), and no compression. Not sure if any of this is helpful or not to my situation.

If there is a comprehensive answer already out there, I'd love to know. thanks for the help!

Posted on Aug 10, 2005 11:51 PM

Reply
22 replies

Aug 11, 2005 7:17 AM in response to Lennart Thelander

Thanks, Lennart. I thought file size shouldn't be a problem, either.

Unfortunately, I have tried opening a completely new, empty iDVD project, to no avail - same duration problem. I must be doing something wrong. Any other ideas?

I have about 19G of hard drive space, so I'm fine there I think.
Any other info anyone can think of I should pass on to help solve this?

Aug 11, 2005 9:15 AM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

Rats. There are cases where a stray audio clip causes the video to be much longer than the user thinks. This audio clip may be just a frame or two, so it can't be seen.

Hmm, you seem to have one, but it's only makaing the video a few minutes longer, not a full hour that I suspected.
Try to zoom in as much as you can on the timeline at extreme right and see if you can delete the stray audio clip.

I have no more ideas. Sorry.
It SHOULD work just fine with 77 minutes.

You may want to try this site:
http://dvd.kentidwell.com/

Aug 11, 2005 3:41 PM in response to Lennart Thelander

Thanks for all your help, Lennart. Sorry I disn't reply earlier, I have been away from my computer all day.

I will try to see if there are any stray files/clips in the movie.

I have a feeling the size problem may be due to how the video tape was originally converted. The original raw digital file wa 14.96 G for a 1 hour 10 minute movie. Does that sound normal or excessive?

If that's too large a file for that length movie I'll have to go back and start from scratch and convert it again. I'm not looking forward to that!

Thanks again for your input. If anyone can answer my question about what is a "normal" file size for a 1 hour movie, I'd appreciate it!

Aug 11, 2005 10:52 PM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

Another question re: video file sizes: does it matter how the video was taped iin the first place? I am doing this project for a school fundraiser so I don't know how it was taped to begin with, probably on the highest resolution setting I presume.

I converted another set of tapes, from another person, total of 2 hours long, and it came out to only 7.5 GB; big size difference from my 1 hour 10 min movie at 14.9 GB. Any ideas on why such a difference?

By the way, I am currently converting the tape again, but it still looks like it will be at least 12-13 GB for 70 min. Hope that will compress in iDVD to fit!

Aug 11, 2005 11:17 PM in response to Lennart Thelander

So if 13 GB per hour is normal, then I'm still back to my original question/problem - why does the iMovie file of 14.5GB say it's too long in duration when pulling into iDVD? Is there something most people do with 1-2 hour videos in iMovie to be sure iDVD can hold it on one DVD?

Sorry if I'm being dense here, I'm still mystified and trying to learn and figure this out.

Thanks for helping!

Aug 11, 2005 11:27 PM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

Sorry if I'm being dense here, I'm still mystified and trying to learn and figure this out.


Don't be sorry. Of course you want your problem solved. I'm mystified, too, as it SHOULD work.

Try deleting iDVD's preferences file: com.apple.iDVD.plist
You need to open iDVD and set your prefs before you create a new project. The most important one is PAL vs NTSC.

The following may also clear "weird" problems, like yours:
Prevent Mac Disasters
Eight Simple Steps You Can Take Now to Keep Your Mac from Falling Apart
http://www.macworld.com/2005/01/features/preventmacdisasters/index.php
(Article is in 3 parts, don't miss parts 2 and 3)

Aug 12, 2005 6:48 AM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

I am having a similar problem. I am using iMovie and importing it into iDVD. I've got 1.5 hours of raw footage of the week of my son's birth, a six minute highlight video, a six minute slideshow, a 5 minute sonogram, and a half hour newscast.

Now, my problem isn't getting it to fit on a DVD. I have ways around that (Jessica, you may want to try to "Save as a Disc Image" and then use a program called DVD2oneX to compress it further. It will decrease the quality, but not to any noticeable degree, unless you are expecting HD like quality.)

My problem is that I am trying to export (Oh, I'm sorry, share) my film into smaller .avi files, for space concerns. But when I share my movie at the recommended NTSC-DV at 29.97 frames per second (In the expert settings Quicktime mode), the files are as big as the original iMovie project file.

So, my question is, what settings do I use to convert the iMovie project into smaller files that can easily be converted by iDVD or Toast into those ISO and VOB type files?

Aug 12, 2005 7:27 AM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

Hi Lisa,

Just a suggestion, not a solution: on your iMovie project file, CTRIL-click and select "Show package contents", go into the Shared/iDVD folder, open the QuickTime move in there. Use "Show movie info" in QT to check the length of the movie now to see if it is 01:12 long as you expected. You can also use QT to inspect for any unusal (stray) tracks. If you find something, go back to iMovie to fix it, and save the project. Good luck.

Aug 12, 2005 7:51 AM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

Actually, I figured out my problem. It may help your problem also. I don't know what program you are using to format your DVD. I am going to use iDVD or Toast. Anyhoo, I am currently exporting to AVI Divx. This will allow me to store my finished 1.5 hour raw footage while working on the other projects, which need to be edited and may also be large.

Aug 12, 2005 9:08 AM in response to Lisa Schmoetzer

A few hours sleep and things are starting to look up! Thanks everyone for the help and suggestions!

I did check the QT show movie info (thanks Hui!) and it shows the file as being 21.88GB. Yikes! The resolution is 720 x 480, 48kHz, 16 bit, NTSC. When I look at the movie in QT it shows it as being over 2 hours long, with the second hours' worth just being white screen. When I look at the exact same, unadulterated file in iMovie it only shows the 1 hr movie. When the playhead reaches the 1 hour 17 min mark, it skips back to the beginning of the movie. Therefore, I was not able to "see" and thus remove anything in iMovie that corresponds to the white screen time I found when playing the file in QT.

Now, I have no idea why there is and extra hour in QT, or why QT info shows the "true" data size of the file and it doesn't show up anywhere else, but my solution (trying it anyway to see if it works) is to convert the movie again (done), check the data size in QT (turns out to be 14 GB, yeah!) and import it back to a new iMovie file (next thing to do). Hope this works!

QUESTIONS: What resolution do people usually use when converting video to DV? Does the resolution of the original VHS recording impact the resolution when it is converted to DV?

Also, Joel, I would like more info on the AVI Divx for storing raw footage files. I am crammed tight for space and need room to maneuver on my hard drives. Could you point me to a web site with info?

Thanks everyone!! I can breathe again!

Getting iMovie file to fit on DVD

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.