Try the following to see if it fixes the issue:
Go into Displays Preferences and put a check mark in the box for "Show displays in menu bar".
Under the resulting icon (looks like an old Apple Cinema Display) in the menu bar, drop down the menu and select "Number of Recent Items" and set it to 10.
Now drop the menu a second time and see if 1920 x 1200 shows up as one of the 10 choices.
If the above procedure doesn't work, you may be a victim of the widespread trouble that several users are reporting after having updated to 10.5.7. You could try downloading the combo updater and running it again to see if that fixes it. Here is a link to the combo updater:
http://support.apple.com/downloads/MacOS_X_10_5_7_ComboUpdate
If that doesn't work, several people have had success using SwitchRes X to restore missing resolutions:
http://www.madrau.com