MBP 13" body is flexing in my bag, rocking on a flat surface

New MBP 13" which I carry around in a bike messenger bag that slings over the back like a backpack might. This means that the macbook is placed slightly across the arch of my spine as I ride. I have found after only 2 days that the machine rocks gently across two rubber feet when placed on a flat surface.

Now, I am only talking a millimetre or two tops here and as it warms up it does tend to settle back into place again. I have read that this is an issue for Air owners due to the thin nature of the device and the advice given by many users was simply "place it over your leg and gently push down on the opposite corners" which although something that works appears to be plain bad for such a compact piece of hardware.

Simply I wonder if this is a known aspect of the unibody design, and if anyone with experience in the situation could say how this might end up effecting the insides of the machine. The flex is minimal, and laptops are designed to withstand being moved about, but I have no insurance on this thing and can only rely on the 3 years of AppleCare should something go wrong in there.

Thanks for any info, all.

13" MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.5.7), cross back bike bag, case flexing

Posted on Jul 10, 2009 8:22 AM

Reply
5 replies

Jul 10, 2009 8:49 AM in response to teddy.

Certainly this is an automatic solution but my worry was not about manually correcting any flex so much as the possibility of the flexing, even a small amount, causing internal flex on the logic board.

I'm worried about the chances of the internal structure of the machine being so tight (because Apple design to be thin) that there is no accounting for this sort of twisting of the body.

As it is I am now using a laptop backpack, but this is a poor solution for me as my bike bag is waterproof and a lot easier to ride with. I've read a few other people notice this flexing in MBP's but it appears to mostly be noted as "rocking on a flat surface".

So really I am asking if anyone knows if Apple's design accounts for the flexible nature of Aluminium!

Jul 10, 2009 9:17 AM in response to James Snook

To be honest, I would be surprised if carrying it this way would bend your MacBook. That's a pretty thick chunk of aluminum in many spots and the structure itself makes it difficult to bend as well. It would have to be pressing pretty hard against your spine for it to actually flex around it.

It also seems a bit odd that it wobbles a bit to start but then settles down. Even with quite a bit more heat than the MacBook puts out, it should not be close to enough to soften the aluminum.

Has this been ongoing or something that just happened once? Have you tried putting it on different surfaces just to make sure that the surface is in fact flat? I would NOT suggest that you try what others have suggested for the Air.

Jul 10, 2009 10:31 AM in response to JoeyR

It genuinely is the case, and not at all hard to cause. Unless my MBP is shockingly defective structurally.

Let me explain more accurately.

My bag is a chrome mini metro (if you wish to see how this works) which has a strap design which holds the bag diagonally across the back with the opening starting at left shoulder and ending by the bottom right rib. The MBP is just long enough to fill this space nearly all the way across and as such will have a diagonal divide across the base against my back with say the back left corner near my left shoulder and the front right corner down toward my right rib, like the bag.

I think what happens is any tug on the strap (light as that may be) causes pressure to be on the front left and back right corners so the flex is again diagonally over my back. This I establish from the way the bag sits and that the MBP rocks very slightly on those two corners feet when on a flat surface (glass desk, table, workstation desks at work etc) so that the back left and front right feet may leave the desk alternately.

Interestingly this only appears possible on in that direction and not rocking across the other two which makes me suspect the framework inside the body is slightly weaker in that direction due to the way it has to contain asymmetric insides.

So when I say flexing the other direction I mean pushing gently on the two corners that rock up and down flattens it out. We are talking a millimetre here, perhaps two. And the pressure applied to reset the shape is less than I would even apply by resting on the machine to type so you can see very minimal effort is required from the bag or my hands.. But yes, I am really worried about this happening either way.

When I say it settles after a while, this is probably due to it's own weight and my hands on it, the pressure really only needs to be that gentle.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

MBP 13" body is flexing in my bag, rocking on a flat surface

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.