10 Replies Latest reply: Nov 18, 2009 10:32 AM by Old Toad
Scott Herman Level 1 (25 points)
I made a CD from iPhoto '09 (8.04) and gave it to a friend running the same version. The CD appeared on his iPhoto as it should and all the data was contained on the CD (original images, modified images, faces and places, titles and descriptions, even keywords & star ratings). Great so far!

But we could not get all this data into his iPhoto. In previous versions of iPhoto all you had to do was drag the pictures from the CD to the Library>Photos in the left column to import ALL data. Now all that did was import the modified images sans titles, descriptions, places, original, etcetera. Same with using the "Import to Library" feature under the File menu.

Any ideas?

Mac Pro (early '08), Mac OS X (10.5.7), 3.2 GHz, 32 GB RAM, 4 TB HD
  • Level 6 (11,040 points)
    I have the exact same issue, and hoping someone out there has the answer. Everything looked fine when we viewed the CD thru iphoto. After import, however, the titles were gone, and I could only view the modified file. The Original was not imported. So, if we wanted to "revert to the original" on the new machine, we cannot.
  • Old Toad Level 10 (135,329 points)
    I just ran a quick test and can confirm what you're experiencing. It's a bug with the latest version of iPhoto. Be sure to report it to Apple via http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphoto.html as I will.

  • Nathan Jones2 Level 1 (30 points)
    Just to concur that I have just discovered the same problem. I will also provide feedback. 8.0.4 has been the most problematic version of iPhoto I've ever used!
  • soespot Level 1 (0 points)
    Is there any software fix available for this problem? I have several photo CD's which won't import their data into iPhoto 9. It will only import the original scanned images, not the edited ones, titles and dates.
  • buttermaker Level 1 (5 points)
    I'm having the same trouble.
    Went on a vacation with friends.
    They gave me their pics on CD exported from iPhoto 09.
    I can't import with metadata into my iPhoto 09.
    Does it matter they're running Snow Leopard and I'm not yet?

    Am I missing something else?
  • Scott Herman Level 1 (25 points)
    I was hoping that the latest upgrade to iPhoto '09 (8.1) would fix this issue. IT DID NOT fix the issue

    I just tried a test burning an event (29 pictures) from iPhoto on my MacBook Pro. When I inserted the disc into my Mac Pro all of the data was contained on it. This is not a change from 8.4 but is very different then what I got with earlier versions of iPhoto ;09.

    Drag and drop the event from the open event window to the Events and it results in loss of all the titles, descriptions and places. NOW it does import the keywords so at least we know they can fix stuff.

    iPhoto '09 has been out for over 8 months with this problem continues. It is frustrating that it is not fixed yet.
  • H S Rollans Level 1 (55 points)
    Just discovered this bug. Maddening! I'll have to put off importing this latest DVD of photos until the bug is fixed.
  • Roger Ptilopteri Level 1 (0 points)
    I had same problem. Solved -- worked around -- by using Finder to drag my files from my DVD to a folder on the desktop. Once that had completed (takes a while for several gig of files of course) I was able to Library Import them (takes a while again for several gig of files of course) from there into iPhoto. This left me with two copies of the files on my mac. I will delete the files from the folder on my desktop and use the ones in iPhoto. Dumb work around but worked for me.
  • H S Rollans Level 1 (55 points)
    I have found a workaround that preserves the titles and comments, and also creates a DVD that is friendlier to Windows and to earlier versions of iPhoto. You can also use it with flash drives. It's not quite as elegant as a Share/Burn, but I think it's going to be my default method from now on.

    Here are the rather painfully specific instructions I sent to my father-in-law:

    1) In iPhoto, select the photos you wish to share.
    2) Go to File/Export...
    3) Select the first tab: File Export...
    4) Select the box: Include: Title and keywords.
    5) Click "Export" (at bottom).
    6) Choose where you would like to save the photos (for example, you could save them into a folder on your desktop, and then copy that folder onto your jump drive or a blank DVD).
    7) Click "OK."
  • Old Toad Level 10 (135,329 points)
    Here's a procedure that should work in getting the photos and their metadata from the library on the disk into the working library. It will require using the paid version of iPhoto Library Manager.

    1 - copy the disk library to the Desktop.
    2 - launch iPhoto and open the disc library to make sure it's the right version, working, etc.
    3 - launch iPLM and add both libraries to the list on the left.
    4 - set iPLM's preferences to get the the events and albums as you'd like. There are a lot of options so look at them carefully. Not positive but I think the default settings will get everything you want.
    5 - select File->Merge Libraries... menu option and then select the two libraries.
    6 - select the name and destination for the new, merged library and go from there.