Dear fellow forum members,
I read all input carefully and I'm also informed there's a history of iMacs overheating, especially the PPC-ones.
As you can see below I'm using a PowerMac G5 at home - without any serious problems sofar - and since two months the company I work for served me very well offering me a new 'left over' early 2008 24 inch iMac, foremost used for graphic purposes.
My impression is that the cramped concept of the iMac has clearly a negative influence on temperature control and that the basic fan settings Apple is using are particularly dictated by silent operation over cooling results.
I downloaded
iMac Fan Control and after careful adjustements I found it very effective in keeping all critical readings at moderate levels.
Besides Apple's never ending problems with nVidia driver software (the new 'old' iMac fortunaly has the ATI 2600 Pro and I would buy a new ATI card for my G5 any day if available), heath is always considered a serious enemy of any electronic device. Especially components like hard discs, TFT-screens (brown stains or non-removable image persistance; I've seen them all) and graphic cards are affected, certainly in the long run. Therefore I rather like my computers operating at temperature levels as low as possible.
And there's another problem. After installing Temperature Monitor I discovered odd (sticky) temperature readings from one of the cores, so I mailed Mr. Bresink what could be the trouble. He informed me that the specific 2.8 GHz processor in my iMac was exclusively built for Apple and that he couldn't get any technical specifications from Intel relating to those custom made components. What seems to be the problem is that a lot of Intel 45nm Core2Duo processors are suffering from defective sensors in one or even both ⚠ cores, causing the systems regulating software getting confused. Nevertheless Intel passed those crippled processors, clearly accepting the risk both sensors could fail in future.
So, overheating is certainly a serious topic and the fact that some forum members could convince Apple delivering them a new computer should be enough reason for iMac owners to keep their eyes wide open for such issues. Odd temperatures reported by iStat or Temperature Monitor, even if they are not that precise, could be a good indication something is wrong.
Best regards,
Robbert