Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

9400m Nvidia screen flicker after snow leopard install

Hi,

I have the late 2008 Macbook Pro Unibody. It ran perfectly with leopard. After installing snow leopard i noticed that the screen flickers (went black) every so often (for half a second) when on 9400m. This seems to only happen after i have put the system to sleep once (i.e. if i turn on the computer fresh it never flickers, but when i put it to sleep and wake it up, the flickering happens). It happens once or twice every 5-10 mins or so. It NEVER happens when i switch to 9600GT discrete mode. Anyone else have this issue?

Imac 20 inch, Macbook Pro (late 2008), Mac OS X (10.5), 2600Pro, 20 inch 2.4 CPU, 2.53MBP

Posted on Aug 30, 2009 2:16 PM

Reply
74 replies

Sep 10, 2009 7:02 PM in response to samt14

Same exact problem for me. I call Apple techline today and they have me reset the SMC. It didn't work at all for me. I had the same problem with 10.5 when I was running on the 9400M but not with the 9600M GT. So it's the same problem with 10.6 but it seems to be even worst... At work I'm connected to an external screen and it flicks as well. So it's neither the laptop screen or a connection/cabling problem with the screen.
I tough it could be about the option of adjusting the luminosity of the screen in the control panel to ambient lighting so I set the luminosity of my screen to maximum and deselect this option. The problem still appears. So it has nothing to do about that either.
There must be a problem either with the board or the driver of the 9400M graphics card.
I didn't find anything on nvidia forum about this problem....
About 10.6, I did a clean install...

Sep 12, 2009 9:03 PM in response to Michael67

This is crazy. I had this problem when I first got my late 2008 unibody but only while under the 'better battery life' performance setting (lower graphics card). It took two visits to the apple store, to where they tried to replace the display (didnt' work) and then replaced the logic board. After they replaced the logic board I NEVER AGAIN SAW THE DISPLAY FLICKER UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES! It was fixed! I use my MBP about 4 hours a day and I never once saw it again for over 6 months. The day that I installed Snow Leopard, it is now happening again. What is going on!? I was convinced it was a hardware problem (with the logic board obviously) but now it's happing again with the OS install. Do I go back to the Apple store or what?

Sep 13, 2009 5:06 AM in response to samt14

Sadly, the problem returned again for me yesterday. I tried to capture it with Jing so I could post it as a bug, but surprisingly, it won't record, even though I can see it happening. That leads me to believe that this isn't a software problem, it has something to do with hardware. Nonetheless, unless it's just a bizarre coincidence, the problem is much worse under Snow Leopard than it was under Leopard.

Shutting down and restarting always seems to fix this problem, and I haven't been able to reproduce it using the 9600.

Sep 13, 2009 5:53 AM in response to samt14

I have the same problem, which starts to get on my nerve.

I don't believe this is a hardware problem. Or it would be one that every new MBP has, and that is activated with an upgrade to snow leopard.

Obviously, some developer at Apple has seen this thread and because of the many replies with all the same problem, they are working on a fix. It's just not Apple's policy to reply to such posts personally, but rather put the fix in an update and only announce it when it is ready.

I for one, can't wait until the update comes. But hey, in the meantime I can always just switch to the higher performance graphics.

Sep 19, 2009 6:11 AM in response to samt14

I'm the original poster of this string. I wanted to report that I've been running the 9600 for the last week and have not experienced any problems, although I see some people say they see the flicker even with this processor.

Regarding the 9400, it sure seems to be related to the way the 9400 NVIDA chipset interacts with Snow Leopard. I, too, had a slight flicker under Leopard, but it never occurred more than once or twice a day. Since I knew I couldn't replicate it predictably for Apple service, I just learned to live with it. Under SL, the problem is really exacerbated to the point where, when it starts, the computer is unusable and I'm forced to shut down and restart to resolve it.

Can anyone narrow down what they're doing when it starts? Are you in a virtual machine, like Parallels or Fusion? Are you using Firefox or Safari? I'm trying to find some commonality that would trigger it, and right now that seems to be a missing piece of information. Since Apple doesn't want to address or acknowledge the problem, it will probably be up to the members of the community to try and narrow this down and see what's causing this widespread issue. It would then be easier to go back to engineering with a method to reliably replicate the problem and get it fixed.

Sep 19, 2009 9:17 AM in response to samt14

I'm not sure all of us are having the exact same problem. Like i said in my original post this only happens to me in snow leopard after I bring the computer out from sleep. I'm don't do any graphic intensive stuff on the computer (no parallels, vmware). I just start the computer, browse the web, put it to sleep, unsleep and read a pdf file and flickering starts. The flickering is often not even the entire screen. sometimes half the screen flickers.

This is just a guess, but i think it make have to do with the driver not clearing the graphic card memory when coming out of sleep (i.e. reinitializing it). And restarting the computer does, thus the flickering stops after a restart. I only suggest this as I had problems with my iMac (ATI) card a few years ago (it kept freezing), and that in fact was the problem, and after the issue was posted all over macrumors, appleinsider and engadget, apple released a fix.

9400m Nvidia screen flicker after snow leopard install

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.