6 Replies Latest reply: Aug 30, 2005 9:30 AM by Brandon Meixel
Camerabug Level 2 Level 2 (395 points)
I recently purchased a PowerMac G5 with an ATI Radeon 9650 video card which has two DVI ports. I was lead to believe that the Apple DVI to ADC Adaptor would provide electric power, video connection, and USB support PLUS provide functionality to the Brightness Button and the ON/Off/Sleep Button on the Cinema Display.

The bottom line, after three long calls to Apple Support and a second DVI to ADC Adaptor, is that the DVI to Adaptor WILL ONLY SUPPLY FUNCTIONALITY to the Cinema Display buttons on video cards that have two different ports - DVI and ADC. If you don't care about the button function on the Cinema Display, then you'll be satisfied with the DVI to ADC Adaptor. All though it is expensive at $99.

At Apple's suggestion, I took my new G5 to a local Apple Certified Repair Center. A tech type worked with me and we tested the ATI Radeon 9650 video card and the DVI to ADC Adaptor on one of their Cinema Displays. It did not work. (That is it provided video signal, power and USB, but the buttons on the display did not work.) But..., when the tech popped in a ATI 9800 Pro card with a DVI port and a ADC port, the DVI to ADC Adaptor worked on the DVI port - it provided electric power, video signal, USB and Cinema Display BUTTON CONTROL.

You can look at a card, with out installing it, and determine if the DVI to ADC Adaptor will work in all respects. The totally functional cards have an extra connection tab that goes into the slot. This supports the Cinema Display Buttons!!! Also, these cards will have an ADC port.

BEWARE! Apple support techs DO NOT UNDERSTAND THIS. Their documentation leads them to believe that the DVI to ADC Adaptor will work with the ATI Radeon 9600/9650 cards to provide Cinema Display button functionality. Wrong, Wrong, Wrong!

Therefore, the real purpose of the DVI to ADC Adaptor is to allow you to attach a second ADC Cinema Display to a video card that has a DVI port and an ADC port.

Apple support techs have (to a person) tried to be helpful. It was their idea to have me work with a local Apple Certified Repair Center to determine what was happening in my case. I've shared with them what I learned. Hopefully, they'll now be able to be more targeted in their support regarding this issue.
  • sillydog701 Level 5 Level 5 (4,120 points)
    thank you for sharing this with us.
  • Ian Oliver Level 1 Level 1 (5 points)
    Er...

    I've got a G5 with a 9650 driving a 22 inch cinema monitor through a DVI to ADC adaptor.

    I just plugged it in and it worked.

    But maybe I'm doing something strange - not a technical person at all.

    Cheers,

    Ol.
  • John Mastrolia Level 1 Level 1 (10 points)
    This is a bit disconcerting. I just ordered a 2.5Ghz system (M9457LL/A) with an ATI Radeon 9600 XT and would like to hook both a 22" cinema display (ADC) and a new 23" cinema display to run them side by side.

    My hope is the ADC adapter included with the machine will do the trick for the 22" monitor. Any incorrect assumptions with expected functionality?

    Thanks.
  • Camerabug Level 2 Level 2 (395 points)
    It will work.

    However, the buttons (on/off and brightness) will not work. This was important to me. Therefore, I got a ATI X850 XT video card which has one DVI port and one ADC port. Now the buttons work on the ADC 20" Cinema Display.
  • Brandon Meixel Level 1 Level 1 (25 points)
    Chiming in to say that it is not a valid to assume just because a video card does not have an ADC port, the cinema display touch sensitive buttons will not work...at my second job we've got two brand new G5's with the 9650, one is connected to a 23 inch, the other to a 22 (both using the DVI adapter) and both work flawlessly. Tap the display symbol and Mac OSX calls up the preference pane. At home I've got my 20 inch ADC hooked up to my powerbook G4 with DVI, and all is well. We've fielded this topic a few times at the Apple Store (my main job) and the results have always been inconclusive. I suggest you try a different DVI port, or different 9650..
  • bug67 Level 3 Level 3 (980 points)
    Yeah, me too. Works great! :/

    But then, I don't use any of the buttons on the monitor either.