Thank you! Here's what I tried:
Setting a password of "apple" (5 characters) for Internet sharing on my Mac, and logging with the Windows laptop using "apple" as a network key. It didn't work.
Setting a password of "apple" for Internet sharing on my Mac, and logging in with the Windows laptop using 6170706c65 (the hex key for "apple" if I understand correctly) as a network key. It didn't work.
Setting a password of "6170706c65" for Internet sharing on my Mac, and logging in with the Windows laptop using 6170706c65 as the network key. It didn't work.
Setting a password of "6170706c65" for Internet sharing on my Mac, and logging in with the Windows laptop using "apple" as the network key. It didn't work.
Unchecking "enable encryption" for Internet sharing on my Mac, and logging in with NO password on the Windows laptop (with the Mac wireless network now showing up as unsecured.) Works like a charm, except for the fact that anyone within a block can tap into my wireless connection.
I'll try the same things with 13-character passwords and 26-character hex keys, and reply again if it works. But meanwhile, what am I doing wrong?
Thanks again.