I love the iMac, especially the later ALU editions. However, my 24-inch, 2008, is now a bit over 4 years. Within the 3 year Apple Care period the screen was replaced 4 times for this issue. Now, a year after the last replacement the smudge is back, larger then ever before and a slightly different "color". Apple stated also "environmental factors, unique to my placement" to be the reason for the problem, but I have had no problems with any other monitor in the same room, on the same desk. As many have stated before me, I believe it to be a combination of the heat buildup and a sensitive white backlight diffuser. The screen now is virtually useless for the photo editing it was initially bought for, and will probably end up in the kids room.
While I've mentally written off this 2800 USD BTO 24" iMac, I am very wary to buy an iMac replacement - is this LCD screen issue solved in the newer models?
I already have a MacMini hooked up to my TV as a media center, works fantastic, but not sure its suitable for my needs on the desktop. The Mac Pro, might be the way to go to avoid these iMac specific smudges but will be (too) expensive.
I miss something between the Mac Pro and the Mini, maybe similar to the old G4 Cube for some expandability and customization...
...or what...???