3 Replies Latest reply: Mar 8, 2010 6:31 PM by Happy Dog
PatsyKB51 Level 1 Level 1 (5 points)
Slideshow created in iDVD, the ultimate product (DVDs) to be given as keepsakes to the surviving family members of a friend who passed away; also to be played at a celebration of life for my late friend.

Photos are old and many - span 83 years - and are all different sizes & shapes.

All I need to decide is what aspect ratio to use - this slideshow may be viewed on computer, TV (regular or H) - I have no idea what people will use.

What's my best choice? Thanks!

iMac, Mac OS X (10.6.2), iPhoto 09, iDVD 09, Photoshop Elements 8
  • Old Toad Level 10 Level 10 (122,325 points)
    iDVD uses the 4:3 aspect ratio. Most digital cameras create images with this ratio. However, scanned photo can be a variety of ratios and will have to be cropped to the 4:3 ratio in iPhoto before sending on to iDVD.

    You can use the photos in their original size if you'd like. That will cause the image to have black bars at the left and right and not fill the screen completely.

    FWIW I find I get the best final image quality when I create the slideshow in iDVD from still photos in iPhoto. The downside to that is the Ken Burns effect is not available and you can have only one transition.

    If you can crop the photos to the 4:3 ratio before using I think you'll have a better looking slideshow. If you use the KB effect don't over do it. Using it on every slide can be distracting making it difficult to concentrate on the actual content of the photo. (You probably can tell I'm not a big fan of KB. )

    If you do create the slideshow in iPhoto be aware that users have had problem with using multiple audio tracks in the export process. Many have found that each track seems to fade out way to soon leaving dead air between tracks. You can add multiple tracks in iDVD and that problem is not present.

    When you're ready to burn the iDVD project first save it as a disk image (File->Save as Disk Image) and check it with DVD Player. This separates out the encoding process from the burn process. If it plays as you expect with DVD Player it's ready to burn. Burn to disc with Disk Utility at the slowest speed available to assure the best burn quality. Always use top quality media: Verbatium, Maxell or Taiyo Yuden DVD-R are the most recommended in these forums.

    Don't hesitate to ask if you have more questions.

  • Chuck Mcfee Level 1 Level 1 (10 points)
    Many of the photos I have cropped (4/3 for TV DVD) and centered. But the effects cut off tops or edges too much. Can I scale the photos down so the effect goes away and the whole photo is seen?
  • Happy Dog Level 2 Level 2 (195 points)
    Sorry, Chuck, no answer. Just a question that may be related:

    The captions that went with each photo in my slideshow carried over to the DVD I created with iDVD. Problem is - when played on the TV, the top halves of the captions are not visible, making them hard to read. Can I do something with the DVD remote so that more of the slide appears? Or do I have to start over? If so, what to do so that the whole caption appears? I sure wish we could put captions at the bottom of the slides instead of upper left.