XSAN // Multiple switches for redundancy

hi guys,

we have a xsan setup running for some time successfully now and recently added a new, second fc switch to have a failover/redundancy in case one fails.

unfortunately this is not working properly and also speed/throughput is not as good as before with the second switch.

unfortunately I'm a newbee so some help would be very appreciated 🙂

2x xserve mdc (each with apple dual fc hba 2x4GB)
5x xserve clients (each with atto dual fc hba 2x8GB)
2x qlogic 5800
1x promise vtrak (2 ctrl.)
1x promise vtrak jbod (attached to above)

we have created 5 luns on the storage

data-1 (xsan lun1, xsan lun2, each 7tb)
data-2 (xsan lun3, xsan lun4, each 7tb)
metadata-journal (xsan lun5, 2 tb)

lun1-4 are raids 1R, 7 hdd x 2tb
lun5 (metadata) is a raid 1 (mirror), 2 hdd x 2tb
+2 global spares

we figured out that this is the most performant setup for our requirements.

with everything connected to a single switch we reach on the clients with the 8GB hbas up to 1.5 GB/sec.

now I've added the second switch, connected each HBA to both switches and also connected the promise raid to both switches (2x switch 1, 2x switch 2), but the data rates seem to be only 50%, and also when I pull the power plug from one switch, the xsan goes offline.

is it a problem with mapping? Or have I wired it wrong?

Posted on Mar 29, 2010 7:14 AM

Reply
6 replies

Apr 13, 2010 11:26 AM in response to acidmac

It would seem to make sense (to me, at least) that if you had all fiber connections stuck in 1 qlogic switch that it would be tad faster than if you had them broken up between two different switches. Especially if the switches were not interconnected via ISL or otherwise. Redudant switches should be inter connected IMHO. But if the good Dr. Kite says otherwise I'd agree with whatever he says.

Message was edited by: Mathieu Mauser

May 21, 2010 1:56 PM in response to wujesson

Let's assume you are talking about two 5000 series QLogic switches with two cascade cables connecting the two...

There are two controllers on the back of the E-Class RAID. Connect one fiber cable from each controller to each QLogic switch.

Controller 1 port 1 = QLogic 1
Controller 1 port 2 = QLogic 2
Controller 2 port 1 = QLogic 1
Controller 2 port 2 = QLogic 2

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

XSAN // Multiple switches for redundancy

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.