K T wrote:
I'm guessing you took a pass on this thread then?
Erm... I sure can't get away with much these days. Seems like there was once a kinder, gentler time when I could lie like a rug and never get caught.
And of all the useless things I do, nothing is quite as tiresome as defending my opinion, especially since I'm usually wrong. But since the issue is fairness, and since our esteemed OP has already dropped 25 to 40 USD on the book in question, please bear with me while I try to spin my previous remarks.
Maybe the search for truth should start with my take on the 3 links you provided:
Link #1: On 3/31/10, Paul Boreham calls the book "rubbish", and writes, It's a nightmare passed (sic) Chapter 14 - its like they stopped caring". On 4/1, both David Moffat and Ramona Adams agree that the quality of the book falls off at Chapter 14. Adams writes, "It was great until then".
The rest of the thread mostly deals with the relative merits of the Apple docs, WWDC lectures, and Stanford CS193P. The docs seem to finish last. Oh.. and also on 4/1, Rufus writes, "Mark and LaMarche use the 'tutorial' method without explaining why you are doing what they say to do". Go figure.
Link #2: On 3/1/10, MobileMan writes, "Sams Teach yourself iPhone Application Development (in 24 hours) by John Ray and Sean Johnson ... Well set up and clean. ... With just this book alone (okay AND Programming in Obj-C by Stephen G. Kochan) I've already made a few programs for the store. It's a fun book to work with".
Sadly some of that thread is pretty hard on the first edition of Erica Sadun's Cookbook. Doesn't it mention somewhere it's a
cookbook, not a primer?
Link #3: This is an earlier (3/28/10) post by Paul Boreham where he writes, "I'm using the SAMs 24 Hour book and struggling a bit from Hour 14-15 (I've found the quality of the book has dropped dramatically with lots of errors... anyway)". There are no replies to that post.
Looking over the reader's comments at Amazon and B&N, typos and incorrect class names were also reported, though I don't think any of those reviews mentioned a drop-off point.
Except for the preview pages I skimmed at B&N, I haven't read the book myself. So what would you have me make of this? Have I read enough to agree the book should be thrown in the trash? We all know which first iPhone book I recommend, and the number 24 doesn't appear anywhere in the title. But I don't believe in one size fits all, and in this thread I'm asked to help the OP use the book that's already been purchased.
Lastly, I think writing a book is an awesomely difficult job. I've skimmed enough of this one to know the authors are clearly trying to teach the subject. If I'd worked my tail off on such a volume for God knows how many months, then read my work was trash in an international forum, then looked closer and discovered the catalyst for this treatment was a misunderstanding about where to get the project code...
Do ya think we could agree to let the OP download the right files, go on to "day 3" or 4 or 12, and then let us know whether the book is working for him or her? If we get bad news at that point, I'm more than willing to admit you're right as usual, KT. Is that fair?
\- Ray