correcting stretched image by wide angle lens

When I shoot with a Canon EF-S 10mm-22mm, the edge of the images are often stretched - people's heads become oval, for example. I tried all kinds of lens correction Aperture plug-ins such as PTLens, only found out that they only correct barrel distortion and perspective distortion, not the "stretch" near the edge of the image. Anyone knows an Aperture plug-in that can correct "edge stretch"? Or is there a function within Aperture (or Photoshop) that does the job? Thanks much.

Mac Pro 2.93 Quad-Core, 12GB RAM, 7TB HD, Mac OS X (10.6.2)

Posted on Apr 21, 2010 7:07 PM

Reply
9 replies

Apr 22, 2010 7:54 AM in response to DLScreative

Well, I think it is not an APS-C issue. I played Canon 5D Mark II with EF 14mm f/2.8L and EF 16-35mm f/2.8L at a Canon experience center and had the same phenomenon - things are stretched at the left and right edges of the images. I figured it should not be a more difficult software than those that corrects barrel distortion and perspective distortion. Just compress horizontally the edges of the image proportionally to the lens. Anyway, it seems that I have to live with it if I want to squeeze more stuff into one frame (I often shoot party events with limited rooms).

Apr 22, 2010 6:35 AM in response to Wanderzhuanyou

You can reshape with Photoshop's liquify tool- it's not just for giving your friends elf ears- but this requires a great deal of skill and time. IOW not worth it.

Line bending is just a characteristic of lenses that wide- and many people use them to achieve that effect. It becomes a problem when one uses them to accommodate smaller APS-C sensors: if one goes wide enough to get the compositon one needs, it often results in unwanted distortion.

You might consider trading that lens off for an aspherical prime like the Sigma 14mm 2.8 (the Canon version is like $1500) which will lessen but not eliminate this effect.

DLS

Apr 22, 2010 8:21 AM in response to Wanderzhuanyou

Yes but with a full frame sensor the camera to subject distance is about the same at 24mm as it is at 16mm on a APS-C sensor so you can get the shot in a tighter space with less distortion. That's what I meant.

People always say that with an APS-C sensor a 50mm is equivalent to an 85mm, a 20mm is equivalent to a 35mm etc. What they overlook is that the 50mm retains the characteristics of a 50mm, and a 20mm retains the characteristics of a 20mm. IOW a 20mm is not a "normal" lens and a 50mm is not a telephoto lens.

One cool thing about APS-C sensors and wide lenses is that the wide look can be achieved w/o getting as close to the subject. I shoot wide because I like that look.


DLS

Try to keep women off the edge of the picture. Most women don't like being distorted, but most men don't care.

Message was edited by: DLScreative

Apr 22, 2010 11:24 PM in response to Wanderzhuanyou

I know exactly what you are looking for. There was a Photoshop plug-in called "squeeze" by the well respected The Imaging Factory, which closed down in 2007. However you can still download it and get a free license key by the look of it.

It does exactly what you want, which is progressively squeezing the edges so that people at the edge of a group taken with a wide angle lens look natural. The centre is unaffected. The conventional lens correction programs do not do this.

There is no UB version, so it is necessary to re launch Photoshop in Rosetta.

I have been hunting high and low for a replacement, so if you find one for Aperture or Photoshop please post here. I have mainly been searching for a Photoshop plugin so maybe there is an Aperture plugin.

I think this is a real opportunity for a developer.

Sorry not to be more help.... I am posting in the hope that someone may come up with something.

Message was edited by: Mike Boreham

Message was edited by: Mike Boreham

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

correcting stretched image by wide angle lens

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.