Paranoia about iSight camera at top of MacBook display: How to cover up?

I know this will sound ridiculous, but I'm paranoid about the built-in iSight video-conferencing camera at the top of my new 15" MacBook Pro i5.

I've already heard rumors of malicious hacker-types who have remotely accessed computers via various means and were able to turn on the videoconferencing function without the (newbie) computer-owners being aware of it -- and then watched or even broadcast live streaming video of the owners and/or the owners' families, who remained blissfully unaware they were even on camera.

I have no idea if this is true or not, but the rumors played in to my pre-existing paranoia about the very concept of built-in video-conferencing cameras. I just don't like the idea of an electronic eye pointed at me all day long, no matter how many reassurances I hear that it is not turned on and not functioning. I'm not enough of an expert to convince myself that it isn't technically possible to turn it on remotely and also disable the "on" light, if some malicious person were to succeed at getting onto my home network via wi-fi or by gaining access of my computer through a sneaky virus or trojan horse or whatever.

This issue would apply to any computer from any manufacturer that has a built-in video-conferencing camera, but I personally own a new MacBook Pro, so that is my specific concern.

Users here may try to convince me not to be paranoid all you want, but I doubt it will be successful. Paranoia strikes deep. What I want to know is NOT how to overcome my fears, but rather how to physically block the camera as effectively as possible without in any way damaging the screen surface or the computer itself.

The simplest and most obvious solution is to place a tiny square of opaque tape on the top of the screen directly over the camera lens. And I'm quite sure that would block it from working and not damage the glass screen cover, since the tape I'd use would be removable. But what I worry about is something esoteric: that the thickness of the tape, even if it's 1/64 of an inch, will interfere with the proper closing of the lid when I shut it; if the screen is designed to press absolutely flush against the wrist-guard when it closes, mightn't the thickness of the tape, in some microscopic way, slightly bend or distort the screen as it tries to press up against the aluminum frame?

Perhaps MacBook Pros are designed to allow a tiny thin gap between the front of the closed screen and the top of the aluminum frame, to allow for crumbs and grime etc. that might accumulate on the bottom-half over time, so that any detritus would not necessarily crunch into the screen when it closes. What if, for example, a nearly-invisible tiny sand grain were on the wrist-guard, and the owner closed the screen on it? Would it go "crunch!" into the glass? I presume not -- I presume that Apple was smart enough to allow some room for play to avoid this problem.

And if so -- if there is enough room for crumbs or tiny sands grains, then there would be enough room for a very thin bit of tape. Agreed? Or am I wrong -- do the two halves, top and bottom, press together with absolute flush precision?

Any opinions on the matter would be most appreciated. If no one answers, I'll just use the smallest bit of the thinnest tape I can find. And yes, I know I sound paranoid, but I have a suspicion that a lot of computer users have worried about the same thing -- being spied on by parties unknown through built-in videoconferencing cameras -- but been too embarrassed to admit it publicly.

15" MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.6.3)

Posted on Jun 11, 2010 6:44 PM

Reply
9 replies

Jun 11, 2010 6:55 PM in response to Tuffy Nicolas

It does sound ridiculous, and it IS ridiculous. But fortunately, if you feel the height of the silicon-rubber rim around your display, you'll find that it's much higher than the thickness of any kind of tape. Into that clearance of about a millimeter, you'll find that you can easily fit a tiny square or circle (such as the one cut out by a paper punch) of black plastic electrical tape. Be careful not to cover up the ambient light sensor as well — it's about 5mm to the left of the iSight lens.

This will leave you without the iSight camera to sweat bullets about, but I suspect you're probably going to find something else to keep you awake at night. Try to relax.

Jun 11, 2010 8:33 PM in response to LowTecLarry

It's not impossible for a remote user/site to access the camera signal, see:

http://www.josephcrawford.com/2006/11/11/scary-isight-trick/
http://www.oreillynet.com/lpt/wlg/7409
http://www.macintouch.com/readerreports/security/topic3999.html

Some security software for the Mac (which you must install so not a hack per se) also allows a remote activation of the camera to identify any 'thief'.

User uploaded file

Jun 11, 2010 10:25 PM in response to iVmichael

IVmichael, from your third link:

+"I experienced something weird yesterday morning.+
+I had Safari open and was just turning iTunes when I heard a computer-generated voice tell me 'I CAN SEE YOU'. I wasn't sure if I really heard this...but I quickly covered up my iSight camera with a post-it note.+

+I just purchased my iMac Dual Core with built-in iSight at the beginning of August. *I have seen the green light flash on and off even when NO programs are open*, including Photobooth and iChat.+
+If it's possible for my camera to be turned on without my knowledge, who's to say they can't hear through the microphone either?"+

Now that is spooky.

And then there's this:

http://boingboing.net/2010/02/17/school-used-student.html

+"School used student laptop webcams to spy on them at school and home+
+...The school district admits that student laptops were shipped with software for covertly activating their webcams, but denies wrongdoing."+

http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Security/Webcam-Spying-Case-in-Lower-Merion-School-Dist rict-Triggers-War-of-Words-636074/

+"The students' MacBook laptops were outfitted with management software called LANrev that could be used to *remotely activate the Webcams*. The district has characterized the technology as a security tracking feature intended to recover lost laptops, and has reported that the software had been used for this purpose 42 times as of Feb. 19."+

Sorry, folks, all these stories are enough to convince me that my paranoia has a kernel of justification.

I like the idea of using a hole-punch to make a perfect circle. Actually, I have some black stickers (made of paper), and I decided I'm going to use that instead of tape.

Thanks for the suggestions and feedback, especially the part noting that the rim around the screen is slightly raised, meaning there is enough room for a thin covering.

I'll mark this thread as "solved" -- and until next time, *+"I CAN SEE YOU!"+*

Jun 11, 2010 10:49 PM in response to Tuffy Nicolas

One final note:

Just did it, took all of 7 minutes:
1 minute to punch out a circle of black sticker with a hole punch,
1 minute to place it directly over the camera lens while not covering the adjacent light sensor -- and then...
5 minutes to GENTLY remove my finger-grease smears with a very-lightly moistened Q-tip!

I'm not kidding when I say that covering the camera like this makes me feel greatly relieved! And the perfectly circular little dot now at the top of my screen almost looks like it was designed to be there intentionally, so is not too distracting nor unsightly (isightly?).

For all you paranoiacs out there, I highly recommend covering up your iSight camera using this method!

Jun 13, 2010 4:43 AM in response to Tuffy Nicolas

I was wondering the same thing after I heard in recent months that a school was spying on students thru school issued macbooks.

i bought my macbook secondhand, and while the thought crossed my mind previously, it was only today that I actually began looking for the camera settings to see if I could find any way that I could tell if it was being remotely accessed. My macbook pro4 doesnt have the indicator light, and I cannot find the hardware settings anywhere.

iSight isnt even a word that comes up in a search...

Does anyone even know how to access the built-in camera settings at all?

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Paranoia about iSight camera at top of MacBook display: How to cover up?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.