Bottom pan bulging - NOT A BATTERY ISSUE

I just got my MacBook back from AppleCare and no one can explain what the problem was so I'm throwing this out there. I was using the MacBook to type some documents on a flat, clean desk when it suddenly moved. It sort of wobbled. The first thought was that it might be the wonderful battery expanding and about to go boom. So I quickly shut the lid and backed away. Several minutes later I turned it over to find the bottom pan - not the battery door - warped outwards slightly. I took off the battery door and the battery was just fine. Repeat: The battery is fine. However the bottom pan and expanded so much that it ripped over two screws holding it to the frame before settling back down.

I called AppleCare and they had no idea so they said go right now to the Apple store. Bless the hearts of my local store they fit me in that day. The guy looked at it and said and I quote "It looks like a little alien tried to give birth in there." He opened it up but didn't see anything wrong with it but said it's definitely a safety issue so he's going to send it to the repair center. Thus whisked away was my precious baby. I was told to call AppleCare the next day to make sure they understood precisely what was going on, explicitly that this was NOT a battery issue. So I did. Never the less every single person I spoke to automatically assumed it was the battery. No one had a clue what it could be.

Today I got it back (bless you AppleCare, repaired and back to me in less than 5 days!) and I see they replaced the bottom pan and the battery door, but that's it. No one at AppleCare can tell me what the techs saw, thought, did etc. further.

Any ideas?

There's one more bit of info that might help: A few months after I got this MacBook (April 2009) I had a problem where any usb device would crash it. The techs at the store took it and replaced the motherboard, but the problem persisted. Finally one of them plugged in an external HD with an OS on it and miraculous it worked. The problem was the OS, not the hardware. So I reinstalled the OS and all worked well, however the system serial number was blank in More Info (About this Mac). Apple techs said this happens sometimes and there's nothing they can do. Well, now since being returned this second time the serial number is back! SHRUGS

So. Anybody else got a Mac trying to give birth? Thanks!

All, Mac OS X (10.5.4)

Posted on Jun 18, 2010 11:33 AM

Reply
3 replies

Jul 22, 2010 7:00 AM in response to jondc

Yeah just sent a Macbook pro 13 inch in to apple care for the same issue. they said and i quote "it is not a battery it is a hard drive screw that was loose the computer was dropped and that is what caused the bulge. We are fixing it under warranty for you" i never dropped the computer and the bulge was a long linear bulge that runs right over the battery. The Tech went on to say "The battery is no where near the hard drive" wow great cover up job apple. way to CYA.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Bottom pan bulging - NOT A BATTERY ISSUE

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.