Is your Macbook Pro one of the newer unibody models with the glossy screens? If so, you may try some rubbing alcohol on a cotton swab to try and remove it. Not sure about nail polish remover -- that's basically acetone, which will eat through pretty much anything. It's safe on glass or metal, but I definitely wouldn't use it on a matte display, and would be hesitant to use it on even a glossy LCD panel since there may be a surface coating that isn't evident.
If you have a matte screen I would try something like iKlear, or a cleaning agent specifically designed for LCD screens. I would be very wary or using rubbing alcohol or any other solvent on a matte screen.