External display not working after installing MacOs Catalina

Hello,


after upgrading my MacBook to macOS Catalina I can't connect external displays. Minutes before installation it was all properly working. It seems like MacBook doesn't detect them at all.

Anyone has similar issue? Any hints?

The displays are not Apple (HP, Asus).


Posted on Oct 11, 2019 5:51 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Nov 8, 2019 6:07 PM

Maybe this might point you in the right direction.


I fixed my full time pink screen issue, here is the solution. I think it might apply to your issue as well. For those of you without working screens, I suggest finding a screen that does work temporarily, and installing Teamviewer, or some other free program to remotely log into your machine. After doing so, connect the nonworking screen, start the computer, and log in remotely, then follow the steps 1-5 below. you will have to switch back to the working screen for the steps 6-15

The reason it is having an issue, is after the update, the signal being sent is YCbCr instead of RGB like your monitors are expecting. Some people with panels like mine will get pink, others likely get no signal recognized. This script works by setting up a profile for your specific monitor, and having it be forced to be RGB, if you connect it to another model monitor with the same issue, this process will need to be repeated for that monitor as well.


  1. Download this script: https://gist.github.com/adaugherity/7435890
  2. Place the patch-edid.rb file into the /Users/ directory
  3. Run this command in Terminal: ruby /Users/patch-edid.rb
  4. Take note of the DisplayProductID and DisplayVendorID file names. These will vary based on your monitor.
  5. Move the output file named "DisplayProductID-XXXX" from /Users/~username/ to the /Users/ directory
  6. Reboot your Mac in Recovery Mode by pressing Command+R as soon as you see the Apple logo after rebooting
  7. Open Disk Utility in Recover Mode
  8. Check to see if "Macintosh HD" is mounted. If it isn't you will need to mount it before proceeding.
  9. Exit Disk Utility
  10. Open Terminal in Recovery Mode
  11. Change to the Overrides directory via "cd /Volumes/Macintosh\ HD/System/Library/Displays/Contents/Resources/Overrides/"
  12. Create the folder with "mkdir DisplayVendorID-XXXX".
  13. Run this command in Terminal (make sure to include spaces):
  14. "cp /Volumes/Macintosh\ HD/Users/DisplayProductID-XXXX /Volumes/Macintosh\ HD/System/Library/Displays/Contents/Resources/Overrides/DisplayVendorID-XXXX/"
  15. Restart computer and the monitor should now be in RGB mode.
  16. Check to make sure it has taken effect by going to your "system preferences" and clicking "displays". If your display name at the top bar does not include "forced RGB mode (EDID override)", it did not take effect.


Hope this helps everyone! if you have issues look in the comments on the script page, the author is active.



My machine is a Mac mini (2018) i7 64GB 1TB. My monitor is a 28 inch Hannspree HF289H monitor

175 replies

May 12, 2020 8:59 AM in response to Ken_Ng_Hawthorne

You've come to the right place...but read the threads on all the pages here. There is nothing new under the sun with your problem. The best bet is to replace the cables to your monitor(s) and mouse (although you are the first person I can recall mentioning the mouse). It's a long and bumpy road...but we are all waiting for Apple to fix the problem once and for all.

Feb 6, 2020 6:11 PM in response to markebrandon

markebrandon wrote:

... nor respond to the many forum posts that requested help with this.


Apple is not here. Apple Support Communities is a User-to-User support forum. If other Users can not help you think of a fix, No further help is likely to be forthcoming using this medium. There are no mechanisms for escalating problems to Apple Support from here, and Apple Engineering and Marketing Movers and Shakers do NOT monitor these forums looking for trends and outstanding issues.


Senior Contributors have been instructed to refer Users with unsolved problems to the "Contact Support" link at the top of every forum page.

Jul 5, 2020 3:55 AM in response to AnBarRua

Thank you @AnBarRua!

YOUR TIP SOLVED my longtime problem, since installing Catalina, and my external screen not working!

Here's my setup and what I did: I use an Apple Macbook Pro 13" from 2016 with top specs together with a first gen Apple Cinema external display. Sharing this so it might help others.


Old setup (that only worked sporadically and very random);

MBP > Apple USB-C adapter > Apple Cinema display normal connection cables (the one with one power and one data cable).


New and WORKING setup;

MBP > Apple USB-C adapter > Apple Thunderbolt cable > Apple Cinema display thunderbolt port on the screens hub. Not using the screens normal display cable as in above setup.


Have not had a single glitch on my external screen since I did this!


BTW & FYI:

I've done the same "trail- & error-journey" as you with every tip on this and other discussion-threads on the net, including trying many different adapters. Nothing worked and it all started when I upgraded to Catalina, before that I never had a problem with my external Apple Cinema display.


Thanks again @AnBarRua for this simple and great solution to this very stubborn problem :)


Oct 11, 2019 12:31 PM in response to Boldvigil

I tried plugging and unpluging several times and shutting down Mac. Nothing worked. Then on another Mac I just left it plugged in and after 30 min it lit up. When I connect and disconnect the screen doesn’t turn on immediately. The other Mac can’t even detect single external screen.

i can’t find any logic in how this works. Sounds like patch is needed.


Has anyone been successful with safe mode reboot?

Jan 8, 2020 4:38 PM in response to SallyAsha

Following up. I ordered a new Apple Thunderbolt2 -> USB-C (yay for $50 adapters) since people have said to try new cables.


2018 Macbook Air <-> Apple adapter <-> Apple Monitor (these cables aren't replaceable)


Does not detect the monitor until roughly 30m-2h later. It does eventually detect it and start working. This problem is repeatable on multiple monitors. I used it for without problems until upgrading to Catalina which is when this problem started. I'm happy to provide whatever debugging info any Apple developer would like.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

External display not working after installing MacOs Catalina

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.