Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Question:

Question: Garageband: Strings sound unusable

Hello. I have been playing around with garageband and making music for a while. I have some training as a viola player and can I just say... I think the strings (and most of the orchestral instruments) on garageband sound HORRIBLE!


I have tried turning the attack all the way down but this doesn't seem to change the fact that strings sound so SLOW and off beat everytime. I can't use them because they always sound off beat from the rest of the instruments I am using. Why is that? Why do they play every note like a slow crescendo and they sound unable to attack the note at the start? This is not how real string instruments sound.


Furthermore because of this they are incapable of playing short notes. If I have section where some notes are shorter (like a bunch of half notes and then some eighth notes) the short notes are inaudible! No real string player sounds like this! Why should the shorter notes be quieter than the louder notes?


Is there something I'm missing?

Posted on Apr 21, 2020 11:59 AM

Reply

May 19, 2020 2:43 PM in response to b_princess In response to b_princess

I completely agree. I’ve been using garageband on my iphone for many years and it’s always been next to impossible to create good-sounding strings, horns– any orchestral instrument, for that matter. The built-in guitar sounds are pretty rubbish as well. Apple seems to only be interested in adding hip-hop drums and synths and, for some reason, obscure “world” instruments, while ignoring other, more common and useful ones. I’ve been waiting for saxophone, accordion, tympani, and even basic hip-hop samples like a decent orchestra hit or record scratch. Some “solutions” I’ve resorted to for strings are as follows: 


Using many staccato notes in rapid succession to create a faux-legato sound with better attack,


Layering a staccato sound on top of a legato sound to create a faster attack,


Shifting the notes backwards so that the attack comes before the beat,


Making my own samples using my crappy phone mic,


Using the “cello” and “bass” sounds in the viola and violin registers to shorten the attack,


Chopping up the “Apple Loops” to create string parts,


and using the “erhu” world instrument, as it has a good, natural, bowed string sound. Strange that they would put so much more effort into such an obscure instrument, huh?


happy composing,

Thin Jim

May 19, 2020 2:43 PM

Reply Helpful

May 19, 2020 8:21 PM in response to thin96 In response to thin96

Thank you!


Tbh I love the sound of the Erhu. It sounds like a beautiful instrument and I love using it. But I don't understand if they can get it so right for the Erhu why not for violin/viola/cello/bass? I mean even the Erhu can't do slurred notes, which is annoying, but I get that that might be a difficult thing to program. But at least it sounds like an actual instrument actually following the score!


My other pet peeve- Staccato doesn't mean a short note! If you enter (for any instrument) a long note, say a whole note, and choose "staccato" it will only make sound for the lenghth of maybe an eighth or quarter note. Staccato means the notes sound jagged and broken up, and on a string instrument it means you switch bow direction btwn each note. But you can still play a full whole note staccato!

May 19, 2020 8:21 PM

Reply Helpful
User profile for user: b_princess

Question: Garageband: Strings sound unusable