2010 iMac won't boot up normally or in safe mode
Hello,
My 2010 iMac has been laggy and prone to freezing for a while, so I regularly have to restart it, but now it won't finish booting up. I get the chime and the apple logo, then the progress bar slowly fills up, and either it stops doing anything during the progress bar or finishes the progress bar and gets stuck on a white screen.
I've tried to boot up in Safe Mode, but it won't get past the progress bar there either. So I tried Recovery Mode and ran First Aid in Disk Repair on the Macintosh HD. It says "First Aid process has failed. If possible back up the data on this volume." Unfortunately I don't have a very recent back up. Don't want to lose anything! Is there anything else I can do?
I'm running El Capitan (I think) - 10.11.6
Thank you.
iMac 21.5″, OS X 10.11