Ok I think I have a solution. I'm new to the apple ecosystem (and on a PC) so this might not come as a revelation to some of you. When you create your log in at podcastsconnect.apple.com that is not the same as creating an Apple ID. Furthermore, when creating a log in for these forums, it is not the same thing as creating an Apple ID. Here are the steps:
Did this on a desktop PC
1) Download iTunes
2) Create an account (this has to be done through the itunes app)
3) Fill out billing info (I chose not to input a CC but the billing address needs to be filled out.)
4) After filling out your billing info and completing the account creation process you will have created your Apple ID.
5) Log into podcastsconnect.apple.com using the login credentials you created via iTunes.
6) It will ask you for the 6 digit code. After inputting it, you should be logged in and see your dashboard.
The key is to create your login and pass THROUGH the iTunes app. This was the info I got from apple podcast support. Hope this helps.